E-Exchanges on the Catholic Church and other issues

E-Exchanges on various issues


*This section of our website (which is updated daily) contains some less formal – and short – e-mail exchanges that we’ve had which we feel may be of value to our readers.  We will include those portions of the exchanges we deem relevant and valuable.  We often add bolding and underlining which are not necessarily that of the other party.  This section also frequently includes, not only e-exchanges we have, but also our notes, updates and comments.  Section containing some important recent posts.*


New Video Posted


MHFM: This is a new video.


The Best Argument Against “Baptism of Desire” [video]



Antipope Francis


Antipope Francis tells divorced woman she should be allowed "Communion"




Subject: Best Argument Against "B.O.D"


Dear Brothers,

That is truly the best argument against the foolish heresy of "Baptism of Desire"! Amazing. One can see how utterly ridiculous this heresy is and so contrary to Catholic dogma.

In Jesus through Mary,




The coming ceremony in Rome, will be the pinnacle of spiritual wickedness, its like not seen since the Crucifixion. The V2 are about to reenact essentially the period between Our Lord's Triumphal entry into Jerusalem, followed days later by his crucifixion. The superficial adoration of Christ the King at Easter, and the intended glorification of Antichrist JP II this coming Sunday, show the V2 church for what it is: shallow and rootless.


It's astounding how impervious they are to common sense and logic! They do not see the parallels in our time, still less the contradictions in their impious attachments. Demons at work obviously! The same demonic entities that were all over Calvary and its environs, are busy still and with much success.


The acceptance of the Vatican 2 Program will reach its apogee/apotheosis this Low Sunday, the day reserved for the so-called "divine mercy" championed by JP II. Whose divinity? Whose mercy? It would seem that Easter isn't quite up to the task that "divine mercy" should follow close on its heels! The brazenness of it! The treacherous spirit of Judas animates the Vatican 2 sect.


Please MHFM, to mark the prerogatives of Our Lord Jesus Christ on this baleful day to come, could you kindly compose a prayer on our behalf; for those who, thanks to your zeal and diligence, have embraced the Catholic Faith. My family will be praying the Rosary as usual…






Subject: Best Argument Baptism of Desire video


Great video and, like the other videos, it tears off the costume of 'baptism of desire' and exposes its utter emptiness.  In fact, so good the video was, I immediately called a few so-called 'traditional Catholics'.  One nun, when asked if 'baptism of desire' grants the grace of baptism/spiritual rebirth, answered a definite "Yes".  I then explained what St. Alphonsus actually taught and so forth.  The nun relayed she wasn't wholly familiar with such Catholic technicalities (can't remember her exact wording) and adamantly affirmed she totally trusts in the SSPX and that the society has done ample research in 'baptism of desire and blood'.  It was quite sad to hear her profound trust in 'man'…  I even read her dogmatic quotes and still, she remained loyal to untruth…


…. thousands of souls will forever meet Hell, as they've fused their hearts to pride, inequities and lies.  'Baptism of desire', 'baptism of blood' and invincible ignorance are alike a devil's fish net that captures 'bad will' and keeps glorifying words of death.  Truth is very simple and 'clear cut', whereas lies are backed by contracting explanations and, as expected, heretics fabricate loopholes that bypass dogma.  The Chair of Peter has spoken and, as the truth says, one cannot enter Heaven without water baptism.  Anything that contradicts this is a lie.   






Subject: Video




Excellent work on your latest video, “The best argument against "Baptism of Desire”.  As you've shown, this heresy has led to other false beliefs… salvation outside the Church. The BOD/BOB heresy can also be attributed to the modern day favorite "who am I to judge" heresy; the current anti-pope's calling card that he uses as he sees fit…


God Bless all your works,

Tom miles




Excellent new video. Visually as well.


You've proven… that many advocates of the so-called BoD/BoB fell into the trap of adhering to the erroneous teaching of a few theologians and saints, which--as you 've clearly shown by analyzing the very definition of the Baptism of Desire which they themselves used…


The main problem with the advocates/supporters of the BoD/BoB is that they tend to ignore all the facts and logically proven, sound arguments. I think they treat the absolute requirement of Baptism of Water, and the absolute requirement of being a member of the Catholic Church for Salvation as an offence. A big one.   They treat those --dogmatically proven by the Magisterium of the Catholic Church-- requirements as unjust, unfair, not-right, merciless.  In their eyes "all good people, all people of the so-called good will" should have a chance of salvation, no matter what beliefs they hold.  They basically, similarly to Protestants, create their own "dogmas", their own doctrine, their own "requirements" necessary for Salvation.  They are basically one of many Protestant sects, only dressed in the 'Traditional Catholic" vestments.  For them the undeniable requirement of the Baptism of Water is a farce/travesty, which can be easily and readily substituted by some vague, full of contradictions, man-made concept of Baptism of Desire…


No doubt


Dear Brothers,


Thank you for your excellent, absolutely irrefutable argument against the horrible heresy of salvation outside the Church through a so-called "baptism of desire" or “baptism of blood”.


There can be absolutely no doubt that the obstinate promoters of this horrible heresy are children of hell as they reject more than 7 infallible dogmatic arguments. But as you pointed out in your announcing audio clip last week, only a few of these heretics will have the sincerity and humility to turn around and admit that they have been wrong – even though the irrefutable and devastating facts stare them right in the face. Sadly, they trust in fallible sources and want to please men rather than embrace and defend the dogmatic teaching of the Church.


Keep up the great work in defending the one true Faith and the one true Baptism of the one Lord Jesus Christ.


God Bless,






I am an ex-protestant. I am considering Orthodoxy, but I also like the Catholic Tradition. Why should I become Catholic rather than Orthodox?... Please give me some guidance. Thanks,



MHFM: You should become a traditional Catholic (rather than “Orthodox”) because the “Orthodox” reject the teaching of Jesus Christ and Sacred Scripture on the Papacy, among other things.  They are not true Christians.  They reject many aspects of what Christ revealed and taught.  That’s proven in the section of our website linked below.  It covers the biblical proof for the papacy, and how the primacy of the Bishop of Rome was acknowledged in the ancient Church.  It refutes the “Orthodox.”  




In that regard we also recommend our book, The Bible Proves the Teachings of the Catholic Church. 


Furthermore, if you are willing to sincerely pray the Rosary and a number of Hail Marys each day for the grace to recognize the true faith of God, you will be moved to embrace traditional Catholicism.  It’s necessary for salvation to be a Catholic.


The Best Argument


Subject: The Best Argument Against “Baptism of Desire”


Breathtaking knockout argument against all the promoters of one of the most destructive heresies of all times: "Baptism of desire".




MHFM: Thanks for the interest.  The facts and the argument covered in the video represent a major victory for the true Church – i.e., for the society of true Catholics in our day who reject “baptism of desire” and adhere to the Church’s doctrine on salvation and the one baptism of water.  The facts and the argument show (once again) that we are and have been correct on this most important matter.  We have the truth and those who oppose us don’t.  We adhere to Catholic teaching, and those who disagree with us don’t.  It’s a matter that, in so many ways, serves to differentiate the true believers in our day from the false ones. 




Subject: elevated


Dear Brothers,


Thank you for the new video.  I was just saying today how 'Baptism of Desire: Buried' is one of my new favorites because it was so thorough and clear; I thought to myself, "This could be a book, by itself, to end all debating on the matter." Then today you posted your new one.  I have to say, you just elevated the faith of every true believer with that work… for that is what dogma and dogmatic truths are - and thereby gave a devastating blow to the heretics.  What's more is that you've empowered all the faithful to defend the truth with perfect clarity, by using the questions and statements you've provided.  It turns us into both defense and offense simultaneously (for the winning team, one might add!)! There is nothing more beautiful, nothing stronger than pure and holy Catholic Faith.  It is truly to die for…  Thank you.


Sacred Heart of Jesus


Subject: Sacred Heart of Jesus


Dear Brothers,

The apparitions of St. Margaret Mary Alacoque are interesting. On June 17 1689, our Lord told her: "Make known to the eldest son of my Sacred Heart [King Louis XIV] that, as his temporal birth was obtained by devotion to my Holy Infancy, so will he obtain his birth into grace and eternal glory by consecrating himself to my adorable Heart. It wants to triumph over his and, through him, over the hearts of the great ones of the earth. It wants to reign in his palace, be painted on his standards, and engraved on his arms, so that they may be victorious over all his enemies. It wants to bring low these proud and stubborn heads and make him triumphant over all the enemies of holy Church.” King Louis XIV, the dancing "Sun King," ignored our Lord's command, and exactly 100 years later to the day, on June 17 1789, King Louis XVI lost his power to the National Assembly of the French Revolution. Could it be that a similar thing will happen in our day? Our Lady of Fatima said that God wanted devotion to her Immaculate Heart. The world has ignored her warnings, accepted the Vatican II antichrist apostasy and worships the antichrist, antipope John Paul II. It could be that 100 years after the miracle of Fatima, October 13 1917, the world will end. It shows how critically important MHFM's work is in exposing the Great Apostasy and defending the Catholic faith. Most Sacred Heart of Jesus, have mercy on us. Immaculate Heart of Mary, pray for us.

God Bless…

Mr. & Mrs. White


Christ’s Doctrine on Heaven


Subject: Christ's Doctrine on Heaven


Dear Brothers:


Former New York City Mayor Michael Bloomberg, apparently thinking about death, was recently quoted as saying that he is sure that when he dies, he will go to heaven.   He rejects Christ and disobeys God -- in fact, he doesn't even believe anything that God has revealed -- but he's sure he is going to heaven.  In addition, Boomberg expresses his view that whoever is in charge at the Gate will be so impressed with Bloomberg's life, such as his "gun control" efforts, that Bloomberg's entrance into heaven will be a shoe-in, and he won't even have to be "interviewed".  He thinks the Last Things involve an interview.  It would be tempting to conclude that hell must be like an insane asylum from which there is no escape, except that we know that hell is even worse than that.  Occupants of hell cannot even escape into their own imaginations/delusions as they are so desirous of doing in this life.  There will not even be the peace of mind that insanity might seem to bring, because the occupants of hell will have an acute understanding of the reality of the evil they have done, of the graces they have spurned, and of the Almighty God Whom they have rejected.  We might picture hell as a place of insanity, but there is no insanity -- only stark reality and comprehension.  And that is the worm that dieth not.


There is so much talk in the world about going to Heaven.  It seems that God is making it clear to everyone that  almost all persons living in the world today imagine that they themselves will go to heaven when they die and that, in fact, just about everyone goes to Heaven.  People either believe that "heaven" is merely the next step in some kind of evolutionary process, or they imagine that since they are so wonderful, God can't help but be overjoyed and impressed by them.  The denial of the consequences one faces by denying the true God and His one true religion is -- as MHFM has so often proven -- is the underpinning of the Great Apostasy which gave rise to the Counterfeit Vatican 2 Church.   And this implicit denial of hell is also promoted by the false traditionalists under the guise of "baptism of desire", "baptism of blood", and "invincible ignorance".   Sacred Scripture and the Catholic Church teach clearly that… to be saved, one must be baptized and hold all the doctrines that Christ taught -- and that not one iota of those doctrines can be changed.  Even a child can understand Jesus's teaching that the path to Heaven is narrow and must be sought and that, because of their own fault, most people end up going to Hell, not Heaven.   Yet, all the world today chooses not to believe Christ's doctrine on Heaven, preferring sin and the false (and extremely temporary) consolations which they derive from the doctrines of men.


Thus, this single, undeniable, and universally-held heresy -- that most persons will end up in Heaven -- is all by itself, a certain sign and proof (which can be comprehended by all) that we are living in the last days.  There can be absolutely no doubt that this is the time that Jesus referred to when He said that, when He returns, He will find almost no one on earth who believes the doctrines which He has given to the world.  And the doctrine on what is necessary to get to Heaven is the doctrine of doctrines, and the summation of Christ's Life, Passion and Resurrection.


Lee Ann



Some thoughts on Francis's "Who am I to judge?"


Deaf MHFM:
Did you notice that when Francis was asked,
"Is there a gay lobby in the Vatican?" he didn't answer the question, did he? He cleverly deflected the issue ("If a gay person has good will etc... who am I to judge?") and the news reporters were so over the moon with what he said, they completely forgot the original question.  And it was a question of great import. 
His answer implied that there
is a gay lobby in the Vatican, and that he is okay with it…






Subject: Extra Ecclesiam Nulla Salus


Thank you so much for creating your book- Outside the Church there is no Salvation, such a wonderful book!  It tells the complete truth which God himself has spoken from the Chair of Peter and there's simply no getting around it period. I especially read and reread the sections… that these BOD heretics love to cling to as proof that this silly notion is magisterial.  


It is so sad to see how most people don't want to accept this truth which our Lord Jesus Christ and the Holy Ghost have laid out for us time and time again throughout the history of the Church… As Scripture says when our Lord comes back for the second time sadly He will hardly find any faith on earth.


I pray that your messages will reach as many people as possible and change lives before the world comes to an end.  Our Lord Jesus Christ have mercy on us.  Our Blessed Lady pray for us.  






the fake movie Heaven is for Real.  Could it be that people gravitate toward… stories like that in order to put a gag on their own consciences?   But how many of them want to hear about the Incorruptible Saints whose bodies are on display all over the world that have not decayed, or hear about the Miracle of the Sun & other verifiable Catholic miracles if presented with the information?  Probably not many.   Look at the multitudes of people who fail to research or look into what the church says… How many people are putting all their stock into some funky "vision" that some 4 year old boy had, whose story has more holes in it than the swiss cheese on my sandwich?   Also how many who claim to be catholic, rave about on how great Medjugorje is but yet don't ever talk about the Fatima nor the La salette messages?   Talk about people brainwashing themselves by wanting to re-enforce their heresies…





Subject: Heaven is for real video


… I read that book when it first came out and at that time I was in the NO VII mess. The people I associated with were of "catholic" & protestant faiths and we were so deceived. We talked about how wonderful this story was and how great God made this little boy see heaven and tell about it. Now that I have found the true Catholic faith and know the true teachings, this story is such a Big Lie that Satan wants so much for us to fall for.  I was one of them but thank God I found MHFM website or I might still be in the dark. Everyone wants to go to heaven but not the way of Jesus, but their own way.  During this time of the Great Apostasy we are bombarded with this message of all the dead are in a "better place." Just turn on tv have you ever seen so many shows about ghost hunters and NDE and mediums talking to the dead?  It's amazing they are all in the "light" or going to it. No one is going to hell. The children of Fatima after seeing what they saw were totally changed forever. They were in awe and they sacrificed their life to God. I don't see anyone who even wants to talk about that, no it's just the feel good stories they want not the truth…





Good Day Brothers Dimond,


I found your videos on YouTube.  I want to be with Jesus in the Eucharist.  I don't want to fall prey to a false counter-Church and commit idolatry unknowingly. 


After seeing many of your videos, I don't know what to do...where to worship?  Where do I find Jesus in the Eucharist?  Is it only in the Latin Mass?  Am I even Catholic?  Is my Baptism, Confirmation, and First Communion valid in the New Mass?  I'm so sad about this information you present and I don't see any solutions?  We have 1 Latin Mass in the Diocese of El Paso at a seminary because the Diocese had to throw the Trads a bone (another long story...)...We went and the Mass isn't even advertised on their Mass schedule.  It's like it doesn't exist.  The seminary doesn't offer any other Sacraments.  Our other option is the SSPX chapel here in El Paso, which you say is no good either.  So I have the NO Mass which you say is invalid (which I completely understand why).  What do I do?  Where do I worship?  How do I raise my children to ensure their sacraments are valid?  I'm so confused, lost and sad.


I must tell you, when I returned to Mass (the NO one), God called me to do things that I felt were out of my control.  They were things I HAD to do.  The compulsion became obsessive until I gave in and followed God's desires for me and how I worship. 


After much prayer, 

I began wearing a mantilla…

I began to kneel for Holy Communion.

I desired the Latin Mass and I have never been to one before I went to the seminary. 

I began to believe that NFP is birth control.


I found your videos and feel like I have no options.  I want to be Catholic.  I want to worship in a traditional Catholic way.  I want to raise my children in the True Catholic Church.  


How can I do that…?


Kindly in Christ,



MHFM: It’s clear that as a result of taking certain positive steps in your life, God led you to the information on our site.  He wants you to see it because it contains the full truth.  Now, to your issues.


First, the material makes it very clear what people need to do.  You need to reject the Vatican II sect, get out of the New Mass and become convinced on all the issues of faith.  For example, you refer to the invalid host of the New Mass as ‘Holy Communion’ when it’s not.  You need to consult the material more thoroughly and adopt the correct positions.


Second, your confusion and sadness is a result of your improper focus and your current insufficient understanding of the situation.  You emphasize where you show up on Sunday when the priority must be the acceptance of the Catholic faith and adherence to God’s requirements.  The practice of Catholicism is not defined by whether you have a church to attend on Sunday.  There were periods in Church history when Catholics had nowhere to attend Mass, but they still practiced the Catholic faith.  The practice of the Catholic faith is much more extensive than where one attends church on Sunday.  There is no obligation to attend a Mass on Sunday if the Church does not provide you with a fully Catholic one in your area. 


Here are the facts.  The New Mass is invalid and basically every priest offering the traditional Mass is a heretic.  There are some options for confession, but few options for the Eucharist today.  For receiving the Eucharist, the priest must meet certain conditions and one must not support him.  One must be convinced on all the issues before receiving any sacraments.  That’s explained in the files below.  We are in the Great Apostasy.  People should pray the Rosary each day (all 15 decades if possible) and the Hail Mary frequently.  Once a person is convinced on all relevant matters, we can help that person with possible locations for receiving sacraments.


The Steps to convert to the traditional Catholic faith and for those leaving the New Mass - Baptism and Conditional Baptism - the Council of Trent's Profession of Faith for Converts


Where to go to Mass or confession today?




Subject: Conversion and Confession of Faith


Dear Most Holy Family Monastery,

I've not contacted you before, but I have been familiar with your material for quite some time now (maybe a few years? I cannot recall precisely). I have finally rejected the Vatican II church and its antipopes and have accepted the sedevacantist position and the traditional Catholic Faith (including the absolute necessity of water baptism and of membership in the Church for salvation). I read aloud the profession of faith promulgated at the Council of Trent and I accept it entirely.

I write both to inform you of this and thank you for making this material readily available and also to ask a couple of questions.

First, as I said, I read aloud Trent's profession of faith for converts; I was not sure whether somebody should have witnessed my confession of faith. Is it required that there be such a witness?

Second, do you know of any validly ordained priests near where I live (Bronx, NY) who I could go to for confession? In one of Brother Peter's debates, he mentioned to his opponent that he knew of such priests around here. I was hoping you could direct me to any of them.

Thanks again for the help in this.

God bless,



MHFM: That’s great to hear.  To your first question, no, in this situation it’s not necessary to make the profession in front of witnesses.  With regard to your second question, please contact us here and we can help you with that matter.  If you don’t already, we recommend that you pray the Rosary each day (all 15 decades if possible) and the Hail Mary frequently.





I saw your website and am trying to find a Mass in Scotland, (Ayrshire), to go to, but I'm not sure which ones to trust. How can I find this, and can you recommend any Masses?

Kind regards,



MHFM: Thanks for the interest.  It's important to realize the situation today (during the Great Apostasy).  It is one in which basically all the churches are either heretical Vatican II churches or 'traditionalist' churches where the priest is heretical in some way.  Thus, there aren't any churches that are fully Catholic, where one can join, regard the priest as Catholic and support the church.  However, there are some options for receiving the sacraments of confession (which is obviously crucial) and possibly the Eucharist (in a traditional rite only) depending upon where one lives, once a person is convinced on all the issues.  Moreover, if one finds an option that meets the criteria, one really isn’t utilizing it for the Mass but simply to receive certain sacraments.  What you need to do is apply the guidelines explained in the file below to the options in your area. 


Before receiving sacraments, one must reach the point where one is committed never to attend the New Mass again, believes in Outside the Church There is No Salvation without exception (no “baptism of desire,” no salvation for those “invincibly ignorant” of the Catholic faith), rejects NFP, won’t support any heretical priests, etc.  That’s explained in this file: Where to go to Mass or confession today?  People should also make the traditional profession of faith from the Council of Trent, which can be accessed from the aforementioned file.  Further, it should be understood that the priests who were ordained in The New Rite of Ordination [PDF File] were not validly ordained.  Since “priests” ordained in the New Rite of Ordination are invalid, any mortal sins confessed to such “priests” must be confessed again to a valid priest once a person is prepared for confession.  Once a person is convinced on all relevant matters, we can help that person with possible locations for receiving sacraments.  We also recommend people to pray the Rosary each day, all 15 decades if possible.




MHFM: This video has some interesting footage of the Blood Moon Total Lunar Eclipse, as it was seen from South Florida.


Blood Moon Total Lunar Eclipse, South Florida April 2014 [1 min. 30 seconds]




Subject: "Heaven is for Real" Video


Dear Brothers:


It's interesting to note that in the video exposing "Heaven is for Real" an excerpt from the book is shown around the 1:58 mark.  The excerpt indicates that the "angels" refused to sing the rock & roll song, but sang "Jesus Loves Me" and "Joshua Fought the Battle of Jericho", both Protestant "hymns."   


This is a standard modus operandi for the Devil - appeal to a false sense of "conservatism" or "traditionalism" in people (i.e. the rejection of the obviously evil rock & roll) but at the same time promote the "lesser" evil (in this case, Protestantism and its "hymns").  This reminds me of how Antipopes John-Paul II and Benedict XVI were lauded as "conservatives" and "traditionalists" because they said a few conservative-sounding things, while at the same time they promoted and participated in the worst forms of heresy and apostasy.


- Mike




Subject: blood of the eclipse




Watching the lunar eclipse tonight (my first) was special (until some weird guy intruded upon it).  While gazing intently at the (barely perceptible) changing color-scape, I was struck with a terrible remorse.  It occurred to me that the moon was like unto a round, white host, and it was lighting up the night for us, just like Jesus Who is the Light of the world.  And when it started to be darkened until there was only a sliver of white, I could hear coyotes howling in the distance, strangely. Then, suddenly it seemed, the 'host' appeared round again, taking on its new reddish hues.  The red began to slowly spread over it, like blood (as it is so aptly called).  This new appearance filled me with remorse for my sins.  It seemed to me that at that moment God was showing the world (using the moon as a movie screen or artist's canvas) a sacred host, bleeding with His Precious Blood, because of the sins of mankind - mankind who crucified Him and who despised Him in the Blessed Sacrament…




Subject: Heaven Video


Dear Brothers:


The video exposing Heaven is for Real is interesting and thought-provoking.  It reminds the listener that the crux of the Great Apostasy is very simple.  It is the rejection of the truth that we are conceived in original sin and need water baptism to go to Heaven.  When the false Christian holds and promotes baptism of desire or any other heresy that denies the necessity of water baptism, he or she is essentially denying Jesus Christ, the Catholic faith, the Bible, the fall of mankind, the history of the world and all of God's creation, revelation and prophecy.   We should not be surprised that the false traditionalists like the SSPX have spent all these years wondering and wallowing around in the desert -- and why they have nothing, and are content with nothing, but externals.  If we weren't born in original sin which had to be removed, why did we need a Redeemer and what were we redeemed from?  Enter Antichrist John Paul II:  men don't need a Redeemer -- each man is his own redeemer.  And this is accepted by almost all today.  We can certainly understand why the apostate Vatican 2 adherent readily accepts all false religions which explicitly deny Jesus Christ, or deny the true Catholic faith.  It is because the Vatican 2 adherent, in reality, rejects Christ as well.  


Millions of abortions can be attributed to the fact that, because they are demonic, the antipopes of the Vatican 2 sect have never even warned (much less "excommunicated") anyone because of abortion.  And, it can be argued, that the false Christians who think they are opposing abortion -- while claiming that babies who die without baptism go to heaven -- are also certainly assisting the demons.   While trying to educate people as to what abortion does to the body, they deny what it does to the soul.


Lee Ann


Hell is for Real


Subject: Hell is for Real


Dear Brothers,

Thank you for posting the video exposing Heaven is for Real.  The message that all one needs for salvation is to believe in heaven is abominable.  It shows the influence of the Vatican II apostasy.  It is the type of message that BOD heretics love.  They might imagine that the boy's experience lends further "weight" to their heresy of salvation outside the Catholic Church.  Instead, it simply further confirms what true Catholics say: that 'baptism of desire' is heresy and leads to hell.  Proof of this is clearly seen in the shocking story about the SSPX priest who raped the three women.  His actions are the bad fruits of apostasy, rooted in 'baptism of desire' and 'invincible ignorance.'  It shows how critical our Lady's message at Fatima was.  She showed the children that hell is for real, and that many, many souls go there.  She urged them…: "Sacrifice yourselves for sinners, and say many times, especially when you make some sacrifice: O Jesus, it is for your love, for the conversion of sinners, and in reparation for the sins committed against the Immaculate Heart of Mary."  That's the real gospel: Acts 26:18 - "To open their eyes, that they may be converted from darkness to light, and from the power of Satan to God, that they may receive forgiveness of sins, and a lot among the saints, by the faith that is in me."

God Bless,

Mr. & Mrs. White


Video – Near-Death Experiences


MHFM: This is an interesting video about the book and the upcoming major motion picture called Heaven is For Real.  The book and the film are based on the story of a 4-year-old boy’s alleged near-death experience.  Not surprisingly, the boy’s story contains a completely false salvation message.  As we’ve mentioned before, almost 100% of near-death experiences are deceptions from the Devil.  Their purpose is to perpetuate the lie that many or almost all are saved and that there is salvation for those outside the true faith and/or for those who die in grave sin.


8 minute video: Heaven Is For Real Exposed


The principle contained in Galatians 1:8-9 is the primary one to keep in mind in this regard.  Indeed, St. Paul’s warning is strikingly on point.  He says that if “an angel from Heaven” (therefore, if someone claiming to have come from Heaven) preaches a different Gospel or salvation message he is to be completely rejected and considered accursed.


Galatians 1:8-9- “But though we, or an angel from heaven, preach any other gospel unto you than that which we have preached unto you, let him be anathema.  As we said before, so say I now again, if any man preach any other gospel unto you than that ye have received, let him be anathema.”


Our Lord’s Agony


Subject: Our Lord’s Agony


Dear Brothers,

Thank you for your amazing videos on the Scourging in Jesus Christ and His profound agony in the Garden of Olives. To quote Bro. Peter: "A trial of sorrow and death had come upon Him...It is reasonable to conclude that Jesus, who had the weight of the whole world's sins on His shoulders, was afflicted with every sorrow and every death in history; every sin; every lie; every murder; every theft; every betrayal; every fornication; every drunken stupor; every instance of unbelief; every act of idolatry or iniquity." Those words strike so powerfully at the heart of this sinner. How can a soul who considers them and the extreme agony of Our Savior (caused by our very sins) not be moved to tears? May Lord have mercy on us who have recourse to Him.

The Agony of Jesus in the Garden – Video

The Scourging of Jesus Christ – Video

St. Isidore of Seville: The greater part of men will set no value on the blood of Christ, and will go on offending Him.

In Jesus through Mary,

New Audio


MHFM: In this file there is a link to a new audio with some brief comments about an upcoming video and ‘baptism of desire.’


Catholic Audios




Subject: Death and the Journey into Hell (3rd Edition)


This is one of the most important videos you will ever see.  It can change your life.  




When in the Vatican II sect


When I was a member of the V-2 sect I also participated in the so-called Taize meetings and prayers. Obviously, at that time, I haven't seen anything wrong with that.  I knew that "brother" Roger was a protestant but I wasn't bothered by that at least.  After all, I thought, "the Catholic Church" fully accepted and sponsored it.  So it was OK in my book. I actually loved the Taize chants and musical prayers.


During my University years I traveled a little with my friends throughout the Europe and slightly beyond. I visited mosques in Turkey, Eastern Orthodox churches in Bulgaria, protestants "shrines " in Paris and Germany, etc…. I did participate in the Jewish ceremony called Bar Mitzvah (couple times)… At that time I didn't see anything wrong with that. I was such an ignorant fool. I also once went for Protestant celebrations. My friend invited me and, again, I didn't see anything wrong with that, and, again. I was a little curious just to see it. "Curiosity kills that cat", I am glad that that it didn't kill me.  In a way, my spiritual life at that time was basically almost dead, although I would never admit it. On the contrary. I thought it was flourishing.


MHFM: What you have described are the harmful results of the false doctrines of Vatican II being accepted, implemented and followed on the local level.  We’re glad you now realize that such activity is wrong and opposed to Catholic teaching.




Dear Brothers


I have always considered myself more so a traditionalist catholic and never did understand the last two "popes" stances upon reading a few books written by BD16 i was amazed to see what you point out as heresy, especially "good" people of all faiths "indirectly" receiving Christ… I myself was baptized in a Methodist Church… After and during the time I attended Catholic school I was amazed at what I was learning and was quickly drawn to the Catholic faith, but I was drawn shy at the fact they were teaching me contradictions. For instance things like, Yes we are they only true church but.... And yes eventually i was converted which today I'm unsure if it was ever official…




MHFM: We’re glad you found the material.  There are no contradictions in the Catholic faith.  The contradictions come from the Vatican II sect, which is not the Catholic Church.  It’s crucial to reject the Vatican II sect, avoid the New Mass and be convinced of all the Church’s dogmas.  You should follow the steps below and pray the Rosary each day.  A conditional baptism should be done, as explained in the file below, once you are convinced on the issues. 


The Steps to convert to the traditional Catholic faith and for those leaving the New Mass - Baptism and Conditional Baptism - the Council of Trent's Profession of Faith for Converts




Dear Brother Michael Dimond, MHFM,


The Truth is what is stated, documented at your website… What you state and document is Catholic Teaching.


It has been apparent for many years that heresies are rampant by means of Vatican II, JPII speaking, what has been said or written, and Benedict XVI. It is impossible to pick up or read any books after Vatican II without some scare of heresy to be found there. Millions of lay people are being lost or led astray.


… JPII during his entire existence on the throne of St. Peter said so many contradictory things, that has caused such mass confusion, that few Catholics really are aware of what the Church's teachings are, furthered by the input of Benedict XVI…


These are threats to the Faith, the Real Faith, and the documentation that you have at your website is a sampling of what is among the worst heresies I believe to ever be preached or taught from the chair of St. Peter.


Not a single Apostle would have been an Apostle if they taught any of the heresies found in JPII or Benedict XVI or Vatican II's teachings or public preaching and writing.


God bless--In Christ, His Holy Mother,




MHFM: We’re glad you are viewing some of the material.  However, no heresy can emanate from the Chair of St. Peter.  The Vatican II ‘popes’ were and are antipopes who never sat in the Chair of St. Peter.  The idea that the Chair of St. Peter can teach error is contrary to Catholic teaching.  It’s necessary to be clear and convinced on that point.




French SSPX priest charged with rape and torture





Seems like major events happen around the time of groups of Blood moons.  The last group of Blood moons occurred with an lunar eclipse in 1967, which was around the time of the introduction of the New Mass.  Also the song 'Hotel California' by the Eagles says, "Please bring me my wine...we haven't had the spirit here since 1969.."  The  changing of the wine and the year 1969 were part of the Vatican II destruction on the world and souls.  Coincidence of these events happening in our time?  I don't think so.



Four Blood Moons


Subject: Four Blood Moons


Dear Brothers,


One would like to comment on the news article on the 4 blood moons, http://www.express.co.uk/news/world/469228/Four-blood-moons-Does-alignment-of-Mars-Earth-and-Sun-mean-the-end-of-the-world-is-nigh. It says at the start of the article that the blood moons occur historically in the past and coincided with global significant event and after a few lines later this one, "Strangely, the last one occurred in 1967 - far earlier than expected - precisely at the time of the Six-Day Arab–Israeli War", They really do not want the VII to be exposed do they? the major significant religious event during that time, if one remembers correctly, is the culmination/closing of VII Council and probably the composition of the New Mass by antipope Paul VI. Oh one understands that this was written in a Jewish perspective then one can say that they expect the advent of their "Messiah" and oh boy would they be shocked if they see Jesus Christ Our Lord coming with the clouds, with all His glory and with 10000s of His angels and saints…


Sincerely and God speed,





Dear Brothers,


I have read through the site and I realise that in many so-called "Catholic Churches" there is apostasy. When I held Protestant views, I had attended "mass" in my "Catholic" high-school and you would not believe it! During a Corpus Christi mass the priest made a positive comment on hindu deities! The best I remember is it was in 2006, I had even accepted the Eucharist from such a priest (at the time I viewed it as only a symbol.) Also the high school that I attended was professing "Catholic" and at the time I had little sense of discernment and couldn't refute the invalidity of such a practice but it was last year I discovered your site, I decided to leave Protestantism and all the errors needed to be un-learned. If I ask too many questions it is not to bother you. I do not want to toy with my salvation. 




MHFM: That’s an interesting story about the apostate Novus Ordo ‘priest’ praising the false Hindu gods.  He’s repeating and applying the teaching of Vatican II.


We’re glad you found the material and have decided to leave Protestantism.  It seems like you agree that the Vatican II sect is not Catholic, that the New Mass must be avoided, etc.  It’s crucial to hold the correct positions on all the issues, pray the Rosary each day (all 15 decades if possible), and follow these steps.  We can help people with where to make a confession, etc. once they are convinced on the issues.  (Also, the New Mass does not have a valid Eucharist.)


The Steps to convert to the traditional Catholic faith and for those leaving the New Mass - Baptism and Conditional Baptism - the Council of Trent's Profession of Faith for Converts




Subject: The ‘invincibly ignorant’


Dear Brothers:


Thank you for the Quotes of the Day, especially the most recent, which clearly show from Holy Scripture that those without knowledge of the Gospel (the Catholic faith) ARE lost. Their minds are blinded by the Devil and the truth is hidden from them. They can and must convert. They can see the witness of creation calling out to them that there is a God and that He must be sought from a humble and sincere heart. Unless they embrace the Catholic faith and receive the Sacrament of Baptism they will most certainly perish in eternity. They will go the way of the wretched ruler Galerius, whose small sore turned into a consuming mortal illness, that could not be abated even with the best work of his physicians, who only made matters worse. This is like the false traditionalists, who do souls no service at all with their cunning theories of "baptism of blood," "baptism of desire," and salvation for the "invincibly ignorant." They are only making themselves and their followers twice as fit for hell.


Joseph Ramirez


Confused in Heresy


Subject: Was Vatican II Infallible? [video]


It is obvious that Vatican II has led many away from much that is Catholic. Has it gone far enough to consider the council contrary to God laws? That is a question that only ones heart can answer. But if it has gone contrary to Dogma and tradition and it remains heretical then one must conclude that Christianity is false and Christ was a liar. But if the council is false and is rebuked then Christian faith will be justified and Christ's truth will emerge unblemished.




MHFM: Your e-mail doesn’t make any sense.  You begin by correctly acknowledging that Vatican II has led many away from the Catholic faith.  You then say that if Vatican II is contrary to dogma Christianity is false.  Immediately after that you write that if the Council is false and rebuked Christian faith will be justified.  That doesn’t make sense. 


Fact: Vatican II was heretical and contrary to dogma in many ways, as the material proves.  That does not indicate that Christianity/Catholicism is false or that Christ’s promises weren’t true; for the men who implemented Vatican II were not true popes, but heretical non-Catholic antipopes.  Moreover, what occurred with Vatican II (and the Counter Church to which it gave rise) is the fulfillment of Christian prophecy about the end times and the Great Apostasy.  Since you don’t look at things with the eyes of faith, you are confused and deceived.  You consequently leap to unwarranted conclusions.  You should pray for faith and clarity and look at the material. 




Dear Brothers,


I agree with your thoughts on gays and lesbians.  God gives them over to this perverse and unnatural vice.  Grave idolatry and mortal sin is the root cause of this condition.  I looked at the book of Romans.  The world is accepting sodomy and gay ‘marriage.’   God bless your website!    In her immaculate heart.  


From mark v




Dear Brothers,

Great to hear you challenged John Daly the BOD heretic to a debate. It would be have been good to hear him get crushed by the truth.  It is astounding how such individuals get away with their lies.  It is outrageous for him (and others) to spread their own heresies, while falsely accusing true Catholics of being "heretics" for holding to Catholic dogma.  Their bad will is diabolical.  One can see it so clearly in operation among the many false traditionalists who roam throughout the internet forums, seeking the ruin of souls.  It is shocking that they push St. Alphonsus' blatant error on 'baptism of desire,' when it has been so clearly refuted… St. Alphonsus blundered on 'baptism of desire,' yet such is "impossible" for the BOD heretics who worship man.  No, what's impossible is that a man can be saved without the Sacrament of water baptism and the Catholic faith.

God Bless,

Mr. & Mrs. White




Dear Brothers,


… So many are dying today without Baptism and without the Catholic Faith.  My mom told me, after she'd witnessed his death, that her dad screamed in terror.  Several weeks later she denied having told me that. Because she is in denial, of course, and currently outside the Church.  My own dad also died apparently unrepentant, after having rejected Jesus Christ and His Holy Catholic Church, and I was the only one in the family who didn't attend his "death and journey into Hell". 


Most recently, I witnessed an apparently unrepentant soul in the death struggle.  I didn't recognize it right away for what it was, but I can't forget it.  This incident has made me realize, more than I may have otherwise, how great a gift is… Catholic Faith; how great is the gift of sight - to see the errors, the lies, the whole Great Apostasy!  To know the truth without any doubt whatsoever; to believe the truth without any hesitation; to happily belong to Jesus Christ! And to denounce Apostate Rome which has become the Seat of the Antichrist… to belong to the Church in Eclipse -- what a tremendous grace!




Subject: Was Vatican II Infallible? [video]


Thank you Brother, for the clear and precise explanation…


Leslie Carver


Traditional Catholics


Subject: Was Vatican II Infallible? [video]


I am confused or perhaps misunderstood. As a born and raised Catholic in the traditional ways here in Malta, i believe the traditionalist conservative catholics are the true Christians because we believe in the traditional old ways of the catholic church are the proper ways, because as you know, liberalism, modernism, protestantism and the heretical new ideas of the nuovus ordo of vatican ii are the works of satan by his worshippers, has plagued our beloved Roman Catholic Church and the papacy, as foretold…




MHFM: Yes, true traditional Catholics are the true Christians.  However, if you watch the video you will see that many groups claim to be traditional or conservative Catholics but adhere to a position that’s incompatible with Catholic teaching.  They reject some of the heresies and false doctrines taught by Vatican II, but obstinately recognize the men who implemented and imposed those heresies and false doctrines as true popes.  In addition to the fact that the Vatican II claimants to the Papacy were heretics and apostates (and therefore could not be true popes), a true pope cannot use the authority of the Magisterium to teach false doctrines to the universal Church in a binding way.  The notion is contrary to Catholic teaching on the infallibility of the Papal Magisterium.  But that’s what many false traditionalists maintain.  Their position is therefore inconsistent with Catholic teaching.  They also remain in communion with heretics and apostates who profess a false faith.  They are thus false traditionalists, not true Catholics.


The Vatican II Church is not the Catholic Church.  It’s a Counter Church.  One must recognize the difference between the two, as our material covers.  The Catholic Church is not led by heretics and it does not teach heresies.  The Vatican II Counter Church is led by heretics who profess a false faith, and it officially teaches heresies.  A Catholic must reject the Vatican II Counter Church and its leaders.  The true position is that the men who implemented and imposed Vatican II were antipopes, as the video and the material on the website prove.




Subject: The Statues of the Antichrist


Dear Brothers,

The images of Karol make me sick because the poses are very similar to that of our dear lord Jesus Christ, the one true God, in order to mock him.

For example, the picture in the Assisi shows him wearing the Crown of Thorns that Christ bore to atone for our sins when he died on the cross and the Fatima picture displays him hunched over but to me it looks like he is covering his wings underneath his "hunch back" but the most offensive one of all is in the Mexico City where Antichrist Karol is standing proudly over the Virgin of Guadalupe, our blessed mother. All of these are just disgusting and horrible but the one word that can truly describe this act… is PURE evil. Yet people continue to worship him. It's just disgusting.

Mary, Mother of the one True God, pray for us.
-John Paul Castillo




Subject: “Gay” NFL Prospect Michael Sam Makes A Revealing Admission [video]


This video is amazing and the gay lifestyle is sick and completely wrong.


Kim Walker




Dear Brothers:


Thank you very much, for all that you do, to expose the false Vatican II church, and to lead people to the truth.  Your videos, such as those about the New Mass, have been very helpful to me…




Dave Phillips






Do you have transcripts available of your recordings? I am interested in your talk on the St Peter as the first pope…


I am in the process of converting some seventh day Adventists and your recording is very thorough.  Also, do you have any proofs on Sabbath vs Sunday?


Thank you,

Rodney Fries


MHFM: We have a book, The Bible Proves the Teachings of the Catholic Church.  You can acquire copies for tremendously low prices.  It contains a section on the biblical proof for the Papacy.  That's what we'd recommend.  This is an article about Seventh Day Adventists, Sunday and the Sabbath: Is Saturday or Sunday the Holy Day according to the Bible?


Image of the Beast in 3D


Subject: JP2’s “Canonization”


Dear Brothers:


The plans to project the image of the Beast in 3D -- around the world no less -- has been described as unprecedented.  Certainly, it could be called an event of biblical proportions -- just like a worldwide flood.  It clearly demonstrates the validity of MHFM's explanation of St. John describing life being given to the image of the Beast… While almost all the world despises Christ and His dogmas, it loves the Beast and his lies.  Thus, in mockery of Our Lord, the world will glorify the Antichrist and his precursor John.  On the Sunday before Easter, the true Catholic Church recalls that the Judeans living at the time of Christ waved palm branches to welcome Our Lord to Jerusalem, but many of these same people, only days later, would traitorously shout "crucify Him".  Is it just coincidence that the Antichrist chose the Sunday after Easter to establish his false feast day?  And was Satan's Man of Perdition mocking mankind when he called it "Divine Mercy Sunday, when he knew it would be a day of Divine Justice?  While no one knows the day or the hour, Our Lord has told us to be vigilant and to watch for the signs which, thank God, MHFM has helped us to understand.  One cannot help but feel that the denouement of the greatest of all Battles in the history of mankind will occur very soon.   


Lee Ann  


“Canonization” of the Antichrist


Subject: “Canonization” of the Antichrist


Dear Brothers,

Thank you for the article about the "canonization" of John Paul II, the Antichrist. It is amazing that it is being broadcast in an unprecedented way, in 3D, HD and 4D technology. The event will use more satellites than the Sochi Olympics. It shows how much the world loves its own. It is further evidence of the fulfilment of the book of Apocalypse, as you wrote, of how St. John probably saw video footage of Antipope John Paul II moving and speaking, "giving life/animation/spirit [pneuma]" to the Beast. An interesting thing was said by the CTV chief, "Monsignor" Dario Vigano: "Vigano underlined that the Vatican decided to offer the canonisation ceremony to the world in 3D in order to give people... the chance to get a “fully immersive” experience." It's interesting that Vigano talks of a "fully immersive" experience. Water baptism is sometimes done by full immersion. It's interesting because the whole Vatican II apostasy, which the "canonization" represents, is a result of the denial of the necessity of the Catholic faith and water baptism for salvation. They want the world to be fully immersed in the Vatican II apostasy.

God Bless,

Mr. & Mrs. White


Debate challenge on ‘BOD’ issued


MHFM: We recently sent an e-mail to a man named John Daly.  He’s a false traditionalist who promotes ‘baptism of desire’.  Like all supporters of ‘baptism of desire’ in our day, he also accepts as Catholics individuals and groups which obstinately teach that souls can be saved in false religions (Islam, Judaism, etc.).  He has promoted St. Alphonsus’ explanation of ‘baptism of desire.’  He has also called true Catholics who adhere to the Church’s dogma (that no one is saved without rebirth of water and the Spirit) ‘heretics.’  We challenged him to a debate on the issue.  Since the issue of ‘baptism of desire’ is so vast, we challenged him to a debate specifically on whether the explanation and definition of ‘baptism of desire’ given by St. Alphonsus (which he has promoted) is consistent with Catholic teaching and should be accepted by Catholics.  He did not respond.  That’s not a surprise.  If we did have a debate, his position (and the position of ‘baptism of desire’) would be destroyed.  Here’s one article relevant to the topic: St. Alphonsus' Blatant Error on 'Baptism of Desire' [article].




Subject: Blood Moon


Dear Brothers,


The upcoming blood moon eclipse on April 15 is just prior to the "canonization" of the two anti-popes, as yet another warning.  Amazing all the theatrics that is being put into this great deception while even having 3D imaging broadcast into theaters.  This act of deception is clearly beyond that of the staged landing on the moon, when considering all the souls that are being lost. 


God Bless,

Tom Miles


“To Give Life to the Image of the Beast”


The image of John Paul II to be projected around the world in 3D during an “unprecedented canonization ceremony”


MHFM: This is a new post concerning the news item above:


“To Give Life to the Image of the Beast”




Subject: Marriage ceremonies and funerals question


Dear Brothers,


I have some serious questions about marriage ceremonies and funerals. First, I want to start out by saying I am a total pre-Vatican II Catholic and agree with everything you guys teach. I grew up Baptist and converted to the Vatican II 'church" about ten years ago. I knew that the Catholic Church was definitely the true faith but I had my doubts on the current church. My family prayed every night for Mary and the Holy Ghost to guide us to the truth and somehow we landed on your website. With that out of the way here are my questions I'd like you to answer.  


1. How would a true Catholic believer get married when there are basically no true priests anymore?

2. Is it wrong to go to a non-Catholic wedding? I have friends and family who won't listen to the truth that I give them. They probably all will be getting married within the next 10 years or so.

3. Is it wrong to go to a non-Catholic funeral? Sooner or later someone in my family will die. If they haven't converted to the true faith, should I go to their funerals?



Ryan H.


MHFM: We’re glad that you came across the information.  To your questions: 1. People can be married without a priest in the current situation.  We can help those who are convinced on all the issues with that matter.  2.  It is wrong to attend a non-Catholic wedding.  3.  It is wrong to attend a non-Catholic funeral.  With regard to #2 and #3, please see this file.


May one passively attend non-Catholic funerals, weddings?  No.




Bros. Michael and Peter Dimond


Hello my name is Henry… and I have been following your web site for about a year, your work is very important to me as you have protected my armor with vital information, however, I trusted my parish in my desperate spiritual needs and time of sorrow with taize prayer offered at 8:00p.m. on the fourth Friday of each month… The fourth time it felt like I was intruding on something I didn't belong in and did not want at all, it is attended mostly by women. Putting a mid-evil painting of Christ on the cross at the foot of the altar with candles around and STANDING NEXT TO IT one or two at a time to pray is to me some occult type of prayer, I would kneel instead.  It felt to me like I was insulting our Lord Jesus Christ so I abandoned it. 


This festered in my head and I looked up taize and to my rude awakening learned it is protestant in the winter 2013, I just received your package and there is Bro Roger Schutz the unconverted? protestant pp265.  Have I unknowingly committed the horrible crime of heresy against my church? I have confessed that I attended 4 taize prayers and learned its founder is not catholic after the fact.  What now?


I would like your feedback in this matter… Henry


MHFM: Perhaps you are referring to something that occurred in the past when you previously attended the New Mass.  We hope you no longer go there.  When people go to the New Mass, things like that will happen.  The New Mass must be avoided under pain of grave sin.  You need to get out of it (if you haven’t already done so) and completely reject the Vatican II sect.  When you are convinced on all the issues, you simply need to confess having attended and participated in a non-Catholic service for however long (i.e., the New Mass), participating in that prayer, and any mortal sins that were not confessed to validly ordained priests.


However, before receiving sacraments, one must reach the point where one is committed never to attend the New Mass again, believes in Outside the Church There is No Salvation without exception (no “baptism of desire,” no salvation for those “invincibly ignorant” of the Catholic faith), rejects NFP, won’t support any heretical priests, etc.  That’s explained in this file: Where to go to Mass or confession today?  People should also make the traditional profession of faith from the Council of Trent, which can be accessed from the aforementioned file.  Further, it should be understood that the priests who were ordained in The New Rite of Ordination [PDF File] were not validly ordained.  Since “priests” ordained in the New Rite of Ordination are invalid, any mortal sins confessed to such “priests” must be confessed again to a valid priest once a person is prepared for confession.  Once a person is convinced on all relevant matters, we can help that person with possible locations for receiving sacraments.  We also recommend people to pray the Rosary each day, all 15 decades if possible.




Bro Dimond,


I have watched several of your videos online and am very fascinated with the information.  I have been raised Catholic and now I am questioning everything that I was brought up believing - even before watching some of the videos…. I'm getting very desperate and need some guidance.


Thank you,



MHFM: We’re glad that you are looking at the information.  The material doesn’t question the Catholic faith, but presents the Catholic faith.  You are probably referring to questioning the status of the post-Vatican II Church.  As the information proves, it’s certainly not the Catholic Church.  It’s crucial to pray the Rosary each day (all 15 decades if possible) and the Hail Mary frequently.  It’s critical to reject the New Mass and the Vatican II sect.  It’s also necessary to hold the correct position on salvation and other issues.  The file below is relevant.  The material explains what people need to do.


The Steps to convert to the traditional Catholic faith and for those leaving the New Mass - Baptism and Conditional Baptism - the Council of Trent's Profession of Faith for Converts




Dear MHFM;


I already have ten copies of 'The Bible Proves the Teachings of the Catholic Church', which is how I found your web site and viewed the 'Third Secret' and your teachings on hell.  Powerful and convicting.  I'm shocked at the apostasy of the last four popes… I will continue to keep in touch with your site www.vaticancatholic.com...


Thank you for your prayers,




MHFM: We’re glad you are viewing the material.  The recent claimants to the Papacy are actually antipopes, not popes.


Faith Alone


My name is Anthony Polenski and I was once an atheist but by God’s grace was called to be a follower of the Messiah, the Lord Jesus Christ. I wanted to write you a quick note as I have been following some of your videos and I have enjoyed them a great deal.

Now, in the video on Rick Warrens son you stated that the protestant doctrine by faith alone is false and I was curious what you meant by that.  I am one who knows that salvation is by faith alone (Ephesians 2:8-9) but I also understand that "faith without works is dead." (James 2)

Can you help me understand what you mean?

I am one who would be considered "protestant" but I go to a "bible believing" non-denominational church. However, even my local body has inconsistencies with the Bible, as I see in many ways the church is more of a mixture between Christianity and Paganism.  My family and I keep the Sabbath and celebrate the biblical feast days. Some would say we are Messianic, but I just say that I am simply trying to follow the teachings of Jesus Christ and the bible alone.

I would be interested to hear your thoughts?...

Blessings in Christ,


Anthony Polenski


MHFM: Anthony, salvation is not by faith alone (see James 2:24).  You are not properly understanding Ephesians 2:8.  You need to see the videos below, and specifically listen to the debate which covers the issue in detail.  These files prove that faith alone is unbiblical and false.  The other material on the website and in the book provide biblical proof for the Catholic faith on other topics.  Protestantism is not true Christianity, and faith alone is a false Gospel.  The traditional Catholic faith is the only true faith of Christ, and it’s necessary for salvation to embrace it. 


The Key to John 3:16 – An important Video Refuting the Protestant Position on Justification [video]


Justification Debate with a Reformed Protestant (Calvinist) [video]




You also hold an unbiblical view about the Sabbath.  You need to see this article: Is Saturday or Sunday the Holy Day according to the Bible?


Cult of Death


Subject: ‘Cult of Death’




RE your news post:  Worship of Satan in Mexico: Cult of “Santa Muerte” has infested Mexico with gruesome consequences


The Mexican Government is no match for the "cult of Death".  General Hernando Cortez and his small army overcame the evil Aztec Empire's cult of Death only by faithfulness to Jesus Christ the Son of God and devotion to His Mother, Mary most holy.  Your video on that subject is sufficient for anyone interested in learning about that great battle; also your video: the Amazing and Miraculous Image of Guadalupe.  To borrow from Sacred Scripture, there is fixed a great chaos between La Virgen de Guadalupe and 'Santa Muerte' - her false 'rival'; neither can it be crossed by either side.  Those who, like the ancient pagan Aztecs, murder victims to appease the god(ess) of death and gain temporal favors, will only be converted (or prevented) if the Mexicans begin practicing again true devotion to the holy Virgin of Guadalupe, which would also require them to convert back to the traditional Catholic faith.  Interesting that the devil keeps 'raising up' false brides and false virgins, like the Whore of Babylon Counterfeit Catholic Church - a false Bride of Christ - and Santa Muerte - 'who competes' with Jesus and Mary in 'granting favors' for the faithless lovers of the world.  Interesting, but not surprising.  Actually, it's not even interesting, because the devil lacks originality! He's just a copy-cat and a thief without shame - he's just a jester; a mocker of all that is sacred who's about to get his head squashed.  If the Mexican Police take Saint Michael for their Patron, they might receive his help, but it seems it is not mentioned in the Biblical prophecies of the last days that any nation will even call on the holy Archangel, except the Christian nation; which is the One Holy Catholic Apostolic Church, now in eclipse.


Apostolic Canons


Subject: Apostolic Canons


Hi Brothers I was reading the Apostolic Canons and found these… they put Burg and the other "popes" completely out of the church.


Canon LXIV.  If any clergyman or layman shall enter into a synagogue of Jews or heretics to pray, let the former be deposed and let the latter be excommunicated.


Canon LXXI. If any Christian brings oil into a temple of the heathen or into a synagogue of the Jews at their feast, or lights lamps, let him be excommunicated.


It is so clear that the spawn of hell that is Burgi is not a catholic with the pictures of him lighting a menorah on Hanukkah. He makes me sick.


~James Keller




Dear Brothers,

Thank you for the comment about how St. Paul saw God, brighter than the sun (Acts 26:13). It reminds one of the Transfiguration: Matthew 17:2 - "And he was transfigured before them. And his face did shine as the sun: and his garments became white as snow." Our Lady of La Salette said that the Church would be in eclipse, as it is now. It is critical for people to recognize the true light of the Catholic faith… There is a great reward for those who persevere in the Catholic faith and in the state of grace: 1 Corinthians 2:9 - "But, as it is written: That eye hath not seen, nor ear heard, neither hath it entered into the heart of man, what things God hath prepared for them that love him."…


God Bless,

Mr. & Mrs. White


Pagan Temples – John Paul II


Dear Brothers:


… I have watched the video on the Third Secret of Fatima and I would like to let you know that I am impressed with the information. Thank you very much! This important video is a true eye-opener. I understand that JPII was a wicked anti-pope and indeed the Anti-Christ. JPII esteemed false religions and worshipped at pagan temples. Indeed, JPII even turned "Catholic" Churches into pagan temples himself. And he preached that every man is God. How evil! It's beyond words.


I have also noticed the quote from The Council of Elvira , A.D. 305: “It has been decreed that those who in adult age after receiving Baptism shall go into the pagan temples to worship idols, which is a deadly crime and the height of wickedness, shall not be admitted to communion even at death.” (Quoted by Amleto Giovanni Cicognani, Canon Law, Philadelphia, PA: The Dolphin Press, 1935, p. 177.)


As a teenager of 15 years of age, and again a few years later at around 20 years of age, when I was still in the Novus Ordo counterfeit "Catholic" Church, I took part in so-called "diocesan" pilgrimages to the Holy Land. We visited most of the beautiful holy sites of the life, suffering, death and resurrection of Our Lord Jesus Christ. But sadly, when in Jerusalem, we also visited two mosques, at least one synagogue and the Jewish "wailing wall", which are all typical tourist spots these days, sadly. Being a typical Novus Ordo person at the time, I did not realize how evil and demonic those places are. I do not remember if prayers were said by the group, and if so, if I took part in them or not. But I do remember touching the wailing wall and also taking off my shoes in the mosque (which I think was a requirement). I don't think I took part in prayers, but I am not certain. Many years have passed and I had forgotten about all this until now.


Now I am worried. Would the above quote from The Council of Elvira apply to me? Is it enough for me to go to Confession, or would the anathema apply to me??? If you could put my mind at ease, I would be grateful.




The Third Secret of Fatima (3rd edition) [video]


MHFM: Thanks for the interest.  The quote from the regional Council of Elvira is interesting and powerful.  It shows how the early Church viewed such matters, and what they would have thought of an apostate such as Antipope John Paul II (and the other Vatican II antipopes).  John Paul II and Benedict XVI not only engaged in pagan rites, but even turned churches themselves into pagan temples so that false gods and idols could be worshipped in them (e.g., Assisi I, II & III; etc.). 


However, the extended prohibition of Communion for such sins was a disciplinary measure.  In your case, what you should do (assuming you agree on all the issues) is simply confess the things you mentioned to a valid priest who says the proper words, as explained in the file on that matter.  We also recommend praying 15 decades of the Rosary each day and the Hail Mary frequently.


“In No Way Judging”


Subject: Article


Dear Brothers,

I was reading the article about the woman who was served a Starbucks coffee in which an employee apparently etched a pentagram and the number 666 in the frothy part of her beverage. The article also mentions that the woman who was served the coffee, is a "Catholic". Well, listen to the following statement she made concerning this incident: “The star is almost okay because it is in your Starbucks logo, the 666, however, was quite offensive,” she wrote. “I am in no way judging his beliefs or dis-meriting his beautiful artwork, I am however judging [the barista's] lack of professionalism and respect for others.” Can you believe it? She says that she cannot judge the beliefs of a Satanist and even calls his satanic "artwork" beautiful! Behold the darkness and religious indifference of the apostate Vatican II sect and its adherents.




Bel, Antipope Francis & The False Traditionalists


…. your video about Bel and Bergoglio was quite astonishing.  I was reading about obama and how much he admired Francis for his work to "teach" people about accepting homosexuality, giving "communion" to abortionists and too much heresy to count. It's funny that when obama said this line, "Wonderful meeting you. I'm a great admirer," It is the same way the false worshipper and King in Daniel Ch.14 said to their false idol, Bel. "You are great, O bel; there is no deceit in thee." People thought they would conflict when in reality, Obama and Bergoglio hold similar heretical views…


Thank you and God bless.

-John Paul Castillo




Dear Brothers:


… When we tell people that the Vatican 2 sect is not the Catholic Church but the end-times Counterfeit Church, they will ask where the true Catholic Church is.  And then we explain to them that the Catholic Church exists in a remnant who hold the true faith.  This is when the discussion begins to get difficult, since only a true Catholic knows what "having faith" means.  In this age of paganism, the adoration of man, and false Christianity, most people equate "having faith" with holding some sort of religion sentiment, whatever that might be.  They think the term "church" or "religion" refers to this building here, or that club or association over there.   To help them understand, I try to explain (if they will let me) that if a person lived in a place where there was never a Catholic church (building) -- or in a communist state where the local church building was destroyed and the priests were killed or deported -- would that mean that people would cease to be Catholic or that their children couldn't be Catholic?  Of course not.  To be a Catholic, they would need to be baptized and to hold the Catholic faith. When St. Francis Xavier and the other missionaries traveled throughout the world, it certainly was not possible for them to leave a church and a priest in every single community they visited.  But they did leave the Catholic Faith. 


God has chosen water to be the matter of Baptism, and He has made water ubiquitous and even necessary for life.  Was this just a coincidence?  And God has made it clear through His Church that any human being can be a minister of baptism.  Another coincidence?  And, in helping us to fulfill the last requirement of baptism, Our Lord has assured us that if a man asks, seeks and knocks -- all works, Protestants should note -- that man will find the salvific truth.  Do the false traditionalists and others who hold and teach the heresy of BOD/BOB consider that God's arrangement of things is all one big coincidence?  They certainly do, and in this they are not much different from the evolutionists to whom everything's an accident.  They will find out someday that damnation, like faith, is no accident.  As MHFM has painstakingly demonstrated in their presentations of the truth about the Second Vatican Council and the counterfeit church which it gave rise to, we are reminded that there are none so blind (or evil) as those who refuse to see.


Lee Ann




Hello, my name is Rob Rawlings, 46, Christian, of England and a relative newcomer to the Catholic faith (of 2 years and counting, after 6/7 years as an unsettled Protestant). Firstly I want to thank you for the VERY rich collection of articles and videos which you have put up on your website to feed people like me who have so many questions and have been striving to cut through so much smog of confusion about various very important issues for the Church and world today. Your videos, articles and perspectives are helping me ENORMOUSLY to get a grip and make sense of various things and so I want to thank you all very VERY much for all the work and dedication that you obviously put into it. The Lord surely is behind you…


Yours sincerely and faithfully,       Rob Rawlings




Dear Brothers, 


I watched your video entitled NFP: A Birth Control Deception as a result, have begun to seriously question the promotion of NFP by the post-Conciliar Church…


It now seems to me that the planning of a family should be left entirely in God's hands… I am an adult convert and the very traditional Priest who received me into the Church has been a widespread promoter of NFP here in Canada.





Natural Family Planning: A Birth Control Deception


MHFM: We’re glad you viewed the video.  It’s important to be convinced on that and other issues.  The priest you mention is unfortunately promoting a sinful birth control practice.  He should not be considered a Catholic guide.  He almost certainly denies the salvation dogma as well.




… Many are steeped in Vatican II apostasy because they break even the natural law, just like the pagans. We have Hindu neighbours. Sometimes, they share their struggles in life. And it becomes evident during conversation that they do break the natural law.... dishonesty, engaging in illegal activities.

The quote from St. Thomas Aquinas in the Salvation book applies to every human being.

"It is the characteristic of Divine Providence to provide every man with what is necessary for salvation... provided on his part there is no hindrance. In the case of a man who seeks good and shuns evil, by the leading of natural reason, God would either reveal to him through internal inspiration what had to be believed, or would send some preacher of the faith to him..."

… God keep Most Holy Family Monastery and Catholics all over the world.






Subject: What Francis Really Believes (3rd edition) [video]


What rubbish!! How can you interpret The pope's words the way you like, just to turn people away from the truth. Praying in a synagoge or anywhere else than in own church doesn't make you a heretic. The pope is trying to bring peace and love between all religions as after all we are all God's children and God loves us all. And who are we to judge how God is going to judge people of good will who are not baptized? Our God is a merciful God and some people unlike you and me have never heard of the Lord What fault do they have if they are not baptized? The pope has done nothing but show love to everyone which we should both be doing. Why not think of that for a while!!!  


Mary Anne Kirkham


MHFM: You are deeply mired in heresy.  You need to learn the Catholic faith and convert to it.  Catholic teaching condemns participation in non-Catholic worship under pain of mortal sin.  It always has.  It also explicitly teaches that the observance of Jewish rites is a mortal sin (Council of Florence).  To practice Judaism or indicate that it’s a valid religion, as Francis does, is apostasy from Christ and the Catholic faith.  The Church teaches that the unbaptized cannot be saved.  That’s a dogma.  When you denounce that truth, you reject defined dogma and the explicit teaching of Jesus Christ Himself (see John 3:5; Mark 16:16).  You say that all are God’s children.  That’s false.  Those who are outside of God’s Church are not children of God.  It’s not charitable or loving to praise false religions or engage in false worship; for adherence to religions of Satan (which is what all non-Catholic religions are) displeases God and leads people to everlasting misery and damnation.  It is thus evil to hide the truth about the Catholic faith, perpetuate lies about non-Catholic religions, or give the impression that happiness or salvation can be attained anywhere but inside Christ’s one true Church, as Francis does.  True faith is the foundation of true charity.  It is therefore most wicked and uncharitable to do what Francis does.  It is heresy and apostasy.  By defending it you commit grave sin and deny the truths of Christ.  You need to look at the material on our website, learn Catholic teaching, change your position, repent and convert; for you don’t have the faith of the Catholic Church at this time.  We recommend that you frequently pray the Hail Mary for sincerity, honesty and the grace to come to the true faith. 


Mock Baptisms


Subject: Mock Baptisms


Dear Brothers,


Yesterday in the Asbury Park Press there were pictures of Mock Baptisms at St Rose Church in Belmar.   I believe it was from several years ago, not current.   My paper runs something called in the past five years remember what was happening..... The mockery consisted on young children bringing their dolls into the church to be baptized by a priest…


God Bless your work,






… RE your statements about the obstinate BOD heretics attacking persons who deny that heresy, focusing on the man and not the argument (since they have no valid argument):  of course, I wholeheartedly agree, having witnessed this atrocious behavior more often than not from those you aptly described as "truly enemies of the faith".  But we are not surprised, as Jesus told us they would do so to us as they did so to Him…




Scripture: "Brighter Than the Sun"


Dear Brothers:

You recently noted that the vision St. Paul saw, of a light from Heaven, which sparked his conversion, was even brighter than the sun:


“At midday, O king, I saw on the way a light from Heaven, brighter than the sun, that shone around me and those who journeyed with me.”    (Acts 26:13)


It's interesting to note that the same phrase "brighter than the sun" was also used by Sr. Lucia to describe the first apparition of Our Lady at Fatima:


"On 13 May 1917 the three children took their flocks out to pasture on the small area known as the Cova da Iria. After lunch and the rosary they suddenly saw a bright flash of something like lightning, followed quickly by another flash in the clear blue sky.


They looked up to see in Lucia's words, "a lady, clothed in white, brighter than the sun, radiating a light more clear and intense than a crystal cup filled with sparkling water, lit by burning sunlight." The children stood there amazed, bathed in the light that surrounded the apparition, as the Lady smiled and said: "Do not be afraid, I will not harm you."




- Mike


MHFM: Yes, another correspondence of Fatima to divine revelation in Scripture is the ‘sea of fire’ the children saw to the ‘lake of fire’ mentioned in Revelation 20:14-15.


Recent Video


Very good, recent video… that proves beyond any reasonable doubt that the Vatican 2 Council was/is considered by the V-2 sect "popes" as infallible and binding. All evidence in the video is very carefully analyzed and the conclusions are based on the documentation that is available for everybody to see.  And the conclusion shows clearly that the V-2 "popes" intended, right from the beginning, for the Synod to be authoritatively binding and "religiously observed by all the faithful".


The reason that many false Traditionalists don't accept these obvious, evident and true facts, and still continue their deceitful claims that the V-2 Council was NOT infallible and that's why not binding, helps them to hold their erroneous position of accepting the V-2 sect's antipopes while, allegedly,"rejecting" the new, anti- Catholic doctrine which was concocted, promulgated and set worldwide in a full motion in order to destroy the True, Real Catholic faith, Church and religion.  The upper echelons of the false Traditionalists… pick and choose of all available documents and evidence ONLY those facts and arguments that fit conveniently their position. It is an extremely dishonest way of dealing with reality. 


The same goes for their followers. They usually don't respond to a logical argument, act as if it doesn't exist and proceed to attacking ad hominem a person who dares to object them. Mocking, ridiculing, calling ugly names, (and I mean ugly, oftentimes vulgar), banishing from the websites, etc., is a big part of their way of handling a debate. It is also worth noticing that quite a few of them, IN SPITE of claiming that they do reject the Vatican 2 Council, propagate the obvious heresies of the V-2 Council.  I know for a fact that many SSPX adherents from Poland proudly, publicly state that the Eastern Orthodox Church is an equal "partner" of the Catholic Church.  They say that the Church of Christ has two "Wings" -Eastern (Orthodox) and Western (Catholic).  Plenty of times I've been insulted by them for opposing this heresy.  Once I asked them " SINCE WHEN the Eastern Orthodox Church stopped being in the schism with the Catholic Church?" . They didn't answer. They just called me names… Sad because out of some false sense of loyalty, and out of some desperate need of "being a part of the group" they are willing to sacrifice the search/quest for the Truth.  In exchange for this comfort of "belonging to the community" they are ready to put a blind eye to the evident, manifest heresies that are being preached to them continuously.  The external package, dressed in a "traditional" wrapping has for them much more value than the internal content.  The Vatican 2 Council was a poison that was very carefully and skillfully prepared in order to paralyze the whole Catholic Church and eventually destroy it.


False Traditionalists agree that it was a poison, yet they don't agree that the people who hand-made that poison were/are wicked, demonic, evil.  They consider this venom to be bad, toxic, deadly, yet the people who manufactured it they still consider as trust-worthy, honest, of good will, honorable, etc.  The venom of the V-2 Council was spread, over the years, all over the world and yielded rotten, cancerous, toxic fruits, yet many, up to this day, claim that those who produced the poison had (have) nothing to do with that.




Hello Brothers,

I would like to know your thoughts about True Catholics visiting the Sacred Image of The Blessed Virgin Mary of Guadalupe in Mexico City?  Seeing how one would have to go into a Novus Ordo church in order to do so... I ask this because over 11 years ago I was in a devastating vehicle collision which nearly took my life. It took the life of a dear childhood friend and left me a quadriplegic. Yet aside for the death of my friend, I am happy for my disgrace for it has brought me out of a sinful life, brought me close to The LORD and with the knowledge of the True Faith. (much of it thanks to your Ministry) . . . The reason I ask is when I was on the edge of death in a coma, my Mother prayed to the Blessed Virgin Mary of Guadalupe asking her to help me. And she promised The Blessed Mother that if I survived that she'd take me to visit her and give her thanks… Well, I know that the Blessed Mother did help me and The LORD gave me another chance at life. If it wasn't for that I've no doubt whatsoever that I'd be burning in Hell this very moment!!!

The problem now is that we're living in the Great Apostasy and I don't go to Novus Ordo "churches", but still my Mother has a promise to fulfill which I want to honor. I would never go in during a quote "mass". Yet lately this dilemma has been constant on my mind and I'm not sure what to do. Maybe The LORD is reminding me, I just don't know? Please advise? Thank you Brothers for all you do in service of The LORD. . . . Sede Vacante!!!




MHFM: That’s an interesting story.  Since the Image of Guadalupe is located in a Novus Ordo church, you wouldn’t have to go there.  Presumably when she prayed for that intention, she didn’t realize the truth about the Vatican II sect and the invalid New Mass.  We believe the only way one could visit the image is if it was not during a service and one handed out Spanish versions of the material (e.g., the Spanish version of the 7-in-one DVD), to evangelize and make the truth available to the people there.


The Amazing and Miraculous Image of Our Lady of Guadalupe (2nd edition) [video]




Subject: Was Vatican II Infallible? [video]


I wonder what some of these dishonest traditionalists will be saying when John XXIII and John Paul II are canonized… to hear their excuses.


Joe Phoenix


What if?


… I was thinking about the change of the wording in the novus ordo mass and suddenly inside of me the question came up, what if the novus ordo mass for the consecration of bishops is changed somehow that the ordination of priests through a novus ordo consecrated bishop is questionable? My questions to you are:

a) Can we 100%  be assured that priests are really equipped with the power to consecrate bread and wine, if they were ordained by a bishop who was consecrated as bishop in the novus ordo? Can such a bishop consecrate valid bishops?  b) To what extent might it be of importance if the bishop's own ordination /consecration was in novus ordo, or if a novus ordo bishop ordains priests in the
traditional/latin ritus?

For me, this question is of vital interest. If the ordination through novus ordo priests is questionable then a lot priests might hand out to the faithful instead of Christ's body a placebo only. In this case I
could also better understand the great apostasy we are facing.


Peter Reisch, Germany


MHFM: Yes, not only is the New Mass invalid, but the new rites of Ordination and Episcopal Consecration in the Vatican II sect cannot be considered valid.  That’s covered on the website and in the material. 


Good Thief


I've been trying to teach my protestant family the catholic faith by showing water baptism is needed for salvation yet they constantly point to the thief on the cross and claim he was saved by faith alone even after. I tell them he is under of the old testament system yet they continue in error someone told me paradise in luke 23:43 wasn't heaven is this true?... There is only one faith the communist feminists have completely taken over mother church all men are feminine that's why they are so indifferent ! The communist Lenin knew how destroy morality by destroying the christian family! That's why it’s hard as heck to convert a novus ordo lay person… I'm getting off topic any info to help prove the church to be true would help greatly!




MHFM: We cover that in this video: The Good Thief, the Old Testament Saints, and the Necessity of Baptism [video].  Also, the true Church cannot be completely taken over.  It can be (and has been) reduced to a remnant, however.




Subject: Catechumens and the Nicene Creed


Dear Brothers.


Thank you for the recent historical post on catechumens. It is further proof that Baptism of Desire is false. The fundamental truths and sacraments of the Catholic Church are so simple and clear, a child can understand them. I think that is how God intended it. Yet these BOD heretics think that there is some cryptic knowledge to fundamental truths, such as baptism. This reminds me of the Gnostics who in their pride think they have some secret, salvific knowledge.


Yet with all this "knowledge" and "deep" understanding they have demonstrated they cannot explain clearly what they believe. Especially when confronted with the teachings of the Church. They think it is wise to believe and proclaim contradictory doctrines in order to conceal their reluctance to accept truth, in order to please man’s sense of justice.   Therefore, it follows that BOD and BOB heretics think the Nicene Creed is wrong or imprecise. Logically they would have to proclaim that one should not hold on to "I believe in one baptism", but that it should be changed to "I believe in three baptisms".  God deliver us from this evil. Let us hold on to the faith of our fathers.


God Bless, In Jesus and Mary,




Vatican II


Subject: Was Vatican II Infallible? [video]


Dear Brothers,


I am incredibly thankful for this video, as it irrefutably proves Vatican II was infallibly promulgated (if it were a valid council) and hence, those who obstinately defend it, must conclude the Gates of Hell have prevailed against the Catholic Church.  In short, Vatican II authoritatively committed itself to heresy.  The demonic darkness and rotten fruits of this false council are as clear as the dayspring sun.  All souls searching for truth should sincerely thank MHFM for working, in my opinion, 'day and night' to further explain these facts.  But sadly, many fake traditionalists spit at truth without even listening and likewise, opt to defend lies, proud man and various antipopes.  SSPX'ers need to stop idolizing the society and humbly open a good Catholic book, such as "The Truth about What Really Happened to the Catholic Church after Vatican II".  


Vatican II's principal duty, as taught by John XXIII, was to defend and promote doctrine… The ecclesiastical Magisterium cannot contradict itself.  Divine truth does not change, nor is God the author of error in man.  It's impossible for the Holy Catholic Church to be defective.  Vatican II was a false revolutionary, anti-Council run by heretics and which initiated a theological revolution.  The Holy Catholic Church has become eclipsed by an anti-Catholic counter church that will continue spewing untruth until it is physically destroyed.  This apostasy is even clearer when recalling that Mother Mary requested the Third Secret to be revealed no later than 1960.  In an interview with Cardinal Ottaviani, on May 17, 1955, Sister Lucia was asked, "Why this date?"  She answered, "Because then it will seem clearer."  Coincidentally, on Jan. 25, 1959, John XXIII announced he had a special inspiration to suddenly call a new ecumenical council.  Also interesting is that, on the same day, an unknown light lit up the skies of Europe, prior to WWII.  It seems both instances were related to the Third Secret.


'Traditionalists' must remember that all deposits of Catholic faith ended with the death of the last apostle.  To change… dogma is to butcher the Holy Gospel.  There is only one faith, one lord, one baptism.  


I thank Jesus Christ for Catholic dogma because it is through dogma that one knows to obstinately reject Vatican II. 






Dear Brothers,


Re: the necessity of water Baptism for salvation


How joyful it was to read your article on unbaptized catechumens, here we see how certain mysteries were temporary concealed from the unbaptised catechumens who were desiring baptism, by reason that they were not considered part of the faithful clearly indicates that although they desired Baptism they were not yet part of the Holy Church.


It is ridiculous to have Baptism of Desire defenders insisting on this issue when it is absolutely clear that the Catholic Church and Holy Scriptures have never taught BOD, this particular precept by the Church at the time only enlightens the mind to this fact and true Papal teaching is also very clear on Baptism of water and its importance for salvation.


Yours sincerely,


In J:M:J:


M.Fernanda da Silva




Subject: Actor James Gandolfini enters the eternal flames


Dear Brothers,


It is interesting to ponder the death of A-List "celebrity" James Gandolfini. Here's a man who had every creature comfort life had to offer... and the esteem and accolades of those of his peers, friends, family and his multiple fans. But now where is James Gandolfini, the "celebrity" who had it all? No doubt he is suffering eternal hellfire this moment, barring the doubtful circumstance he happened to convert to the true Catholic faith, and made a good confession before his massive heart attack. But sadly, I doubt that was the case. All of the riches this man enjoyed in the temporal world were all for nothing, and he has found out he couldn't take any of it with him.






Subject: Question about the book entitled "The Bible Proves the Teachings of the Catholic Church"


To Whom it may concern:  I read the article on your website entitled “THE BIBLICAL BASIS FOR PRAYING TO MARY AND FOR CATHOLIC TEACHINGS ON MARY”.  Is this full article included in the book entitled, “The Bible Proves the Teachings of the Catholic Church” by Bro. Peter Dimond.  If so, how much would the book cost including shipping.  The article was the single best article I have read on Mary.  I am currently a member of the Anglican Network in Canada.  It is only a matter of time until I become Roman Catholic.  There are still some issues that I am trying to figure out.    I live in Burlington, Ontario, Canada. 


God Bless,

Peter Myyry


The Biblical Basis For Praying to Mary And For Catholic Teachings On Mary [PDF]


MHFM: We’re glad you read the article.  It is part of the book, The Bible Proves the Teachings of the Catholic Church.  The prices for the book are listed on our online store: http://www.mhfm1store.com/.  It’s crucial that you become Catholic and leave Anglicanism; for Anglicanism is not true Christianity.  It’s necessary for salvation to be a Catholic.  However, one must become a traditional Catholic, as the material on our website covers.  One cannot become a member of the Vatican II Church, for the Vatican II Church is not the Catholic Church.  That’s explained in the material on the website, in the videos, articles, etc.  We recommend that you start to pray a number of Hail Marys each day for the grace to come to the true faith.  If you are willing to pray the Rosary, you should do that as well.


Brighter than the Sun


MHFM: It’s interesting that the vision St. Paul saw, of a light from Heaven, which sparked his conversion, was even brighter than the sun. 


Acts 26:13- “At midday, O king, I saw on the way a light from Heaven, brighter than the sun, that shone around me and those who journeyed with me.




Dear Brothers  


I find this whole sex abuse scandal in the Novus Ordo as proof that it is not the true Catholic Church.  It’s truly evil/ sick/and diabolical.   Also there was an earthquake recently in southern California…


In her immaculate heart from Mark V




Subject: Recently decided to convert to the Traditional Catholic Faith


I was raised in the Vatican 2 Church.  I used to believe that Protestantism was pretty much the same as Catholicism because of the teachings of Vatican 2 and I embraced many Protestant heresies.  Through research I later learned that there is some distinction and began to see myself as a Catholic.   


More recently and mainly through your website, I have come to the conclusion that the “Popes” since and including John XXIII cannot be Popes and must be antipopes because their public teaching blatantly contradicts the past dogmas of the Church…




MHFM: We’re glad to hear about the interest.  It’s important to be convinced on all the issues and follow these steps.  Also, it’s crucial to pray the Rosary each day and the Hail Mary frequently.


The Steps to convert to the traditional Catholic faith and for those leaving the New Mass - Baptism and Conditional Baptism - the Council of Trent's Profession of Faith for Converts




The "Is the World About to End" video was absolutely incredible. I shared it with a few people…





Subject: Catechumens, BOD heretics


Dear Brothers,

Thank you for the quote about the distinction between unbaptized catechumens and the baptized faithful.  The 'baptism of desire' heretics prove themselves liars repeatedly.  Only the water baptized are members of the Catholic Church, the faithful.  It's also interesting that the catechumens knew the essential Mysteries of the Catholic faith, such as the Trinity and the Incarnation, yet were kept ignorant of some of the deeper Mysteries, such as Transubstantiation.  Maybe this was to protect the baptized faithful from false converts, or weak catechumens who would compromise under persecution, from the false Romans' accusations, such as of cannibalism.  The BOD heretics are the lowest and most dishonest of heretics, since they deny the very thing they claim to be defending, and the only thing that can save a soul from hell - the Catholic faith.  Like the gates the hell, they attack souls with lies since they have been given over to a hatred of the Truth.

God Bless,

Mr. & Mrs. White


MHFM: You raise an important point.  The discipline that developed of concealing certain things from the unbaptized (particularly the truth about the Body and Blood of Our Lord Jesus Christ) was not a requirement of apostolic Tradition.  It was, rather, a practice that developed as a tactical way to prevent further persecutions.  (It’s referred to as the disciplina arcani).  For one of the pretexts utilized by Roman authorities and enemies of the faith to carry out persecutions was the allegation that Christians were subversive or a threat to ordered society.  Hence, if dishonest unbelievers and pagans heard portions of the doctrine that Christians eat the Body and Blood of Jesus Christ, they might (and sometimes did) equate that with cannibalism.  Such a distortion of Christian truth on the Eucharist would thus provide more ammunition for evil men to call for persecutions against the Church.  As a result, the discipline developed that some of the truths were to be withheld from the unbaptized.  Eventually the practice disappeared as the situations that gave rise to it (e.g., vigorous persecutions in the Roman Empire) ceased to exist.


The fact that unbaptized catechumens were (as usual) categorized with pagans and unbelievers, with whom such knowledge was not shared, is another example of the truth of apostolic Tradition (and the defined dogma) that only the water baptized are part of Christ’s faithful.


Sr. Lucia, Baptism


Subject: Sr. Lucia's words, baptism




As I was listening to the Third Secret of Fatima video, a thought occurred to me regarding Sister Lucia's words about us having to choose sides, i.e., that there will be no more 'in between'.  I believe that is happening now rapidly.  Many have already made their choice, but I believe we will see it completed before our very eyes…


Today is Friday of the Third Week in Lent.  I wanted to share what it says in my 1953 Missal, for it once again supports the Church's teaching on Baptism.  In Rome, the Church celebrated this day at the Station at St. Laurence's in Lucina.  This is one of the numerous sanctuaries built at Rome in honour of the martyred deacon.  Part of the gridiron on which he was tortured is kept there.  This church, one of the twenty-five titular or parish churches of the Christian capital in the fifth century, is still to-day that from which the first of the Cardinal Priests derives his title.  It was during the forty years passed in the desert that Moses and Aaron asked God to bring from the rock -- a figure of Christ -- "a spring of living water", so that all the people could quench their thirst.  During these forty days of Lent the Church asks Christ to give us the living water about which He spoke to the woman of Samaria near Jacob's well, that water which quenches our thirst forever.  This water is our faith in Jesus, it is grace, it is the blood which flows from the wounds of the Saviour, and which, through baptism, penance and the other sacraments, purifies our souls, and gushes forth into eternal life… We should note the parallel that it pleased primitive Christian art to establish between St. Peter and Moses.  The latter touched the rock from whence the water surged; this is a symbol of Christian baptism given by the church of which St. Peter is the head.


New Video Posted


MHFM: This is a new video on an extremely important topic. 


Was Vatican II Infallible? [video]


This video is a must-see for all who claim to be traditional or conservative Catholics.  If one were to list the main reasons why some “traditionalists” still accept the Vatican II “popes” as true popes despite having problems with the Vatican II Church and the teaching of Vatican II, the idea that Vatican II was “not an infallible or binding council” would be at the top of the list.  This a major issue.  This video carefully examines the matter and completely refutes the false traditionalist position.  In addition to discussing in detail the main aspects of the issue, the video contains numerous very important new points.  The new points include quotes from John XXIII’s opening speech at Vatican II that will certainly surprise or even shock false traditionalists who for years have been fed misinformation on this matter.


Catechumens are not part of the Faithful


MHFM: As our salvation book shows, one of the numerous dogmatic proofs against ‘baptism of desire’ is the fact that there is no salvation at all outside the faithful, and only the water baptized are the faithful.  In fact, Church teaching and Tradition specifically exclude unbaptized catechumens from the faithful. (Section 6 of our book, Outside the Catholic Church There is Absolutely No Salvation, covers this).


Below is a somewhat interesting quote from a pre-Vatican II book on dogmatic theology about the clear division between unbaptized catechumens and the baptized faithful.  The quote concerns how things were often concealed from catechumens because they were not baptized and thus not considered in the society of the faithful.  (Note: this is not to endorse the following book in everything it says, but simply to share the interesting quote.)


Sylvester Joseph Hunter, Outlines of Dogmatic Theology, Vol. 3, pp. 166-167, A.D. 1894: “The Greek word corresponding to 'Sacrament’ in its Christian use, is ‘Mystery.’ (n. 16.) This word points to the special care with which the Christian rites were concealed from the heathen, and even from the catechumens, who had not received Baptism, just as the priests at certain heathen shrines practiced secret rites, the nature and inner meaning of which was disclosed to none but the initiated. That the same discipline prevailed in the Christian Church is well brought out by a passage where St. Augustine uses an illustration drawn from the profound ignorance of the catechumens on certain matters which were familiar to all the baptized.  If asked whether they believed in Christ, they will answer that they believe, and sign themselves with the sign of the Cross; but if asked whether they eat the Flesh of the Son of Man, they will fail to understand what is meant.”




Francis' embracement of… Obama… is very telling.  Evil simply flows from Obama's pores, and he radically accepts every moral and social teaching the VII sect still claims to oppose (although Francis has cast doubt on this through his interviews, and given an excuse to many wicked VII newchurchers to not oppose them).  Would or even could a true pope embrace a world leader or any man such as he?


Michael Rudnicki in Christ


MHFM: A strong Catholic would not embrace such a man.  Rather, he would firmly admonish him for endorsing various evils and attacking the Church.  He would call him to change his ways and convert to the true faith.  He would do that prior to any meeting.  As a result, there wouldn’t be a meeting if the evil man did not change his positions (e.g., if he did not cease his persecution of the Church).



MHFM: One thing you notice about obstinate supporters of ‘baptism of desire’ is not only their penchant for misquoting things and completely falsifying sources, but they like to attack the person and not the argument.  Since they cannot defend their position, they attempt to make the individual who denies ‘baptism of desire’ the focus of any discussion, rather than the dogmatic facts which refute their position.  Ultimately that approach doesn’t help them, either; but it’s worth noting.  They are truly enemies of the faith.      




My name is Marcus. I was raised "Catholic" in Wisconsin. Roundabout when I turned 18, I removed myself from the church. It wasn't because I'm an atheist, or that I despise religion or Catholics. I didn't really know why I distanced myself from it.

I came upon your youtube channel and website and was very pleased to see someone from one of the "major religions" actually talking about real issues such as the New World Order, etc.

I have a few questions I hope you can answer, if you have the time.

1.) At what point in history do you believe religion, mainly Catholicism, took a turn towards evil? I'm not sure if that's the best way to phrase the question. Please briefly explain the history of the Church and when it became blasphemous.

2.) Zionism and the treatment of the Palestinians...There is a lot of talk in the anti-NWO world about Zionism. I am familiar with the history of Zionism in the modern sense, with the Rothschild family basically behind it, making deals with Hitler to send 30,000 Jews to Palestine and create a "Jewish state". What are your thoughts on Zionism?

3.) I have read a lot of literature by top level "globalists" calling for world government. What is the biblical significance of a world government?

4.) and finally, would you agree that the major religions of the world are nothing more than control mechanisms to carry out an ancient tactic of "divide and conquer" so that we as humans never obtain full spiritual enlightenment?

That is all for now. Thank you for your time.

Marcus Gruenstern


MHFM: Marcus, we’re glad that you are looking at the material.  Let us address your questions, in order:


First, we don’t believe that Catholicism took a turn for evil.  The Catholic Church is the one true Church of Christ, as our material covers.  It’s necessary for salvation to belong to it.  What we point out is that the Vatican II Church is not the Catholic Church, but the prophesied end-times Counter Church.  You should watch these videos.  They explain the situation:


Is the World about to End? – The Apocalypse Explained? [video]

The Third Secret of Fatima (3rd edition) [video]


Jesus Christ was true God and true man, as He proved by His life, death and Resurrection.  He founded a Church and revealed the path to salvation.  It’s crucial that you look at the material and become convinced of the Catholic faith.  If you are willing to pray the Hail Mary each day – even perhaps five or ten times a day – you will receive some graces.  You should do so and ask the Blessed Virgin Mary to help you avoid Hell.  If you take those small steps, you will then have more interest in the true faith.  At that point you will need to take further steps.  The prayer is attached.  But you need to act upon this information.


To your second question, we address those issues on our site. 


Third, the first video above explains how an end-times empire fits into biblical prophecy. 


Fourth, men cannot obtain enlightenment without Jesus Christ and faith in Him.  That’s the only way to be enlightened.  The Church He founded is thus not a control mechanism to keep people from enlightenment, but the only way to that enlightenment.  All the other religions are creations of the Devil to keep people from the true faith and lead them to Hell.


Anti-Catholic Protestants


Subject: Your website




I've enjoyed looking at your website. I grew up as a very conservative Protestant but have really struggled with it and with people like John MacArthur or Jack Chick who insist that Catholics unsaved. I've since distanced myself from all of that, and want to find the historic apostolic Church. Do you know how to connect to traditionalist Catholics in my area? I live in the Ozarks, which isn't the most Catholic-friendly area...how do you deal with anti-Catholic Protestants?






MHFM: We’re glad you are looking at the material.  For dealing with anti-Catholic Protestants, we recommend the book The Bible Proves the Teachings of the Catholic Church and the section of our website that refutes Protestantism.  A good place to start is with the doctrine of justification/salvation; for the group that has the biblical doctrine of salvation is the true Church.  That’s the Catholic Church, of course.  Therefore, among other things, the material that refutes the Protestant view of justification/salvation is important to emphasize.


You mention John MacArthur.  He’s a Calvinist.  This debate directly addresses and refutes the views of heretics such as MacArthur.  Sadly, those people are without any doubt false Christians who lead people to Hell.


Justification Debate

The Key to John 3:16


It’s not clear if you are a traditional Catholic at this time.  It’s crucial that you become convinced of all Catholic teachings and follow these steps to convert.  It’s crucial to pray the Rosary each day and the Hail Mary frequently.


The Steps to convert to the traditional Catholic faith and for those leaving the New Mass - Baptism and Conditional Baptism - the Council of Trent's Profession of Faith for Converts




Subject: Leeda Crawford


Dear Brothers:

Emails like the one from Leeda Crawford make me shiver, because they remind me of persons I knew back in the Vatican 2 sect.  Like Leeda, such pompous individuals imagine themselves to be authorities in what they falsely believe is "religion", and they are awed by their imagined sense of self-importance in this and in most things.  Although I didn't fully understand it at the time (as I certainly do now),  I can recall recognizing even then that there was no point in trying to tell some of these people anything at all -- because they thought they knew everything.  One could actually perceive their displeasure at being corrected, and the very suggestion that they might be wrong would make them bristle. 


Just like Leeda.   She begins her bluster with "Let me tell you what I know", and proceeds to reveal that she knows absolutely nothing.  It is really sad how the devil dupes these people into believing that they are the Church Militant when they are blind fools and stooges of the Whore of Babylon.  But what is most bizarre of all, is how people like Leeda never seem to be the least bit disgusted or repulsed (as they should be) by the filthy heresies, blasphemies and blatant denials of Jesus Christ --  all of which define the official Vatican 2 sect.  Instead, it is truth which is repugnant to them!    Like all the rest of the liars which MHFM has exposed, they are way beyond simply "indifferent".  They defend the filth and the denial of Jesus Christ -- but attack and despise MHFM for telling the truth.  False Catholics are just like the rest of the world, only worse.  They don't just call evil good, and good evil. They willingly and enthusiastically accept Satan in the place of God.


These people who feign love for Christ and His Church -- when in fact they despise Him -- help us to understand why God in His Wisdom and Justice has allowed the Counterfeit Catholic Church and its antipopes to arise in these last days.  God has given the world exactly what it wants.


Lee Ann


Antipope Paul VI


Subject: Was Vatican II Infallible?


Dear Brothers:


Your new video is irrefutable. The Vatican II antipope John XXIII clearly intended the Council to define doctrine and therefore be an exercise of the extraordinary Magisterium, which of course, he did not possess. Antipope Paul VI simply acted according to John's lead, and solemnly promulgated heresy, hundreds of times over. The gates of hell--the death-dealing tongues of heretics--prevailed at Vatican II, therefore, the organization that stemmed from it, which now calls itself the Catholic Church, but is not, CANNOT possibly be the true Catholic Church. How much clearer does it have to be for Novus Ordo conservatives and false traditionalists to wake up and come out of their fog?


Joseph Ramirez




It is very interesting that the false-traditionalist sent the email only one or two minutes after the new video was published.   In his impropriety, he simply couldn't wait to contradict, with no facts mind you… the position which was unsettling to him… A nonbinding pastoral council… was the only cliche he could come up with on the spot.  Perhaps if he had waited at least an hour after the video was published, he could have been deceiving into making it appear as though he had at least watched the video.  Perhaps he thought the email would not be seen right away so he could have gotten away with his scheme.  But then he would have appeared to have been an even more dishonest liar in denial, that he can't have his cake and eat it too.  If the VII antipopes were real, then a true Catholic, as in days of old, could never just pick and choose which councils or which documents or teachings could be ignored or followed.  And here we are, 2014, and the illogical non-sedevacantists still cling to their illogical position…


Sincerely, Michael Rudnicki




Subject: Was Vatican II Infallible - Video


Dear Brothers,

Thank you for the excellent video proving that, had the Vatican II claimants to the Papacy been true popes, Vatican II was infallible. John XXIII makes it very clear in his opening speech to the Council that it is a teaching of the Magisterium.  He says it is of the "never-failing" Magisterium, which is the same words Vatican I used to describe the unfailing Magisterium.  Vatican II also deals with matters of faith and morals.  The false traditionalists have nowhere to run from these facts.  The myth that Vatican II is "merely pastoral," is absurd and clearly contradicts what the leaders of the same false traditionalists declared.  Vatican II is about the modernist "methods" the Vatican II defenders are to use to explain Catholic doctrines.  The "methods" in their case actually turn out to be the heresies - the heresies of Vatican II are therefore binding for anyone who obstinately holds to the Vatican II antipopes.

God Bless,

Mr. & Mrs. White




Subject: Debate: Dimond vs. Sungenis 


WOW!!! I had listened to your debate with Sungenis before, but never read the transcript until last night, and again today. His arrogant bad will is clear in the audio… the conclusion can only be that Nostra Aetate #3 is heretical on several points and Mr. Sungenis is attempting to defend the indefensible with the most outrageous and devilish speech I think I've ever heard in any of your debates with heretics. His love for Jesus Christ is equal to the love for Jesus Christ that Paul VI, John Paul II or Benedict XVI held for Him - ZERO.


I would not be surprised if Mr. Sungenis' head was spinning on his neck while he denied your valid claims of heresy in that "Vatican II" piece-of-garbage document.  He obstinately denied what you so clearly and painstakingly proved, e.g., that the V2 church esteems the Muslims AND their religious practices and that the V2 church and the Muslims adore the same "one" God.  As if that wasn't evil enough, he also asserts that since Nostra Aetate #3 wasn't declared heretical by Paul VI (or his "successors" in the anti-Chair), then he, Sungenis, isn't going to consider the possibility of its heresy.  It doesn't matter to his hard heart and heretical mind that Nostra Aetate #3 IS a denial of dogmas defined by true popes of the past, since he, Sungenis, has separated himself from them.  It's interesting that he falsely asserted that your proving the heresies of Nostra Aetate #3 is "going around in circles" when he was the one circling around it like a pack of devils in a circle guarding the center where the evil enters.  His use of invalid technicalities is insulting to Catholic intelligence:  he said, "the word 'true' is not used here".


He contradicted himself numerous times:  " the Islamic faith and the Catholic faith have a common ground, and that is in the fact that they worship one God. So, that’s what’s being esteemed by the Catholic Church".  Sungenis doesn't see how he defeats his own attempts to defend the apostasy by such statements. He admits that the V2 Sect 'esteems' the Muslim or 'Islamic faith' for the 'fact' that they 'worship' one God.  This is just one example of his self-contradictions and the heretical doctrine he espouses.  It's clear from his closing statement that Sungenis wants a church of the world, i.e., an Antichrist church, which would not be at war with Christ's enemies… How could anyone who considers him/her self to be "Catholic" have any respect for his opinions after hearing this debate?!


Vatican II Debate – on Nostra Aetate #3 and the Muslims (Transcript)




Subject: Sedes - Debate




First of all, thank you for the recent transcript from the debate.  I remember listening to it a couple of years ago and thinking how dishonest R.S. was.  As for the clown who commented about Sedevacantism, I wonder if it was someone I may have taken to task recently who fancies himself a strong, traditional Catholic!  In the last couple of weeks I have engaged a few conversations on Facebook exposing the false Vat II sect and their blatantly heretical antipopes… It is so disgusting the way they base their foundation upon the comfort of following a man and not the truth of the See of Peter…

Thank you for all you do.  You work and website is truly the work of God,






Subject: Video


Dear Brothers,


Your latest video, "Was Vatican II Infallible" shows just how evil that council was/is… The research and development, had to have taken years to complete, prior to 1960 and it was just a matter of time before the freemason puppet-masters launched their diabolical charade to the world's public audience through their phony elections.  Furthermore, the average "Catholic" layman would never have known what hit him when that VII diabolical tsunami hit the shores of his hometown, unless he was one of the few deeply-seated in the traditional Catholic Faith.  Over time and through your hard work, we're seeing the rotten fruit that has fallen from the limbs of Satan's end-time VII counter-church.  Hopefully this video will shake a few false-traditionalists out of their decaying tree of false beliefs.


God Bless,

Tom Miles




Subject: Was Vatican II Infallible? - Video


Dear Brothers,


Your video was truly a work of the Lord and completely refutes any false "traditionalist"… Sadly, there are still many who are expecting the veneration of both antipope John XXIII and the notorious AntiChrist Karol (aka John Paul II)…


Long live the True Catholic Faith

-John Paul Castillo




Subject: Was Vatican II Infallible?


Hopefully, bad willed "traditionalists" would watch the video. Some are so allergic to truth, they may be inclined to just run from the evidence, lest their false reality be devastated before their very eyes…


Melina Wisky




Subject: Was Vatican II Infallible?


This presentation refutes the claims of the SSPX and other self-styled conservatives that Vatican 2 was merely a pastoral council…


Rainer Hofstedt




[MHFM: This is an e-mail we received literally about one to two minutes after posting our new video, Was Vatican II Infallible?  He sent the e-mail before he could have possibly even watched more than a minute or so of the new video.  He’s so willingly brainwashed that the very title of the video caused him to react with the following communication, before viewing the evidence.]


Subject: Was Vatican II Infallible?


No, it was Pastoral in teachings, it had nothing to do with Faith and Morals or Sacraments.


D.R. Daily


MHFM: We responded: You really need to watch the video because you are quite wrong and you don't know what you are talking about.


Benedict XVI’s Jesus of Nazareth, The Infancy Narratives


Subject: Sadly some are believing this harmful and hurtful interpretation of Pope Benedict's books and actions and the other Pontiffs as well


I know from scripture Jesus Christ and His disciples would not support what is said and implied in this video or on your website.  


The Secret Intentions of Benedict XVI's Book, 'The Infancy Narratives'  http://www.mostholyfamilymonastery.com


Let me tell you what I know from our Lord's words what will happen to those who are spreading horrible scandal.  You will have to answer to Our Lord Jesus Christ for the harm you have caused and persons you have misled by your analogy's.  You sound like St. Pius the X Society to me, although your website seems to discredit them.  St. Pius X himself would not support what you are doing!  I find you are doing the same action as the Society.  Discrediting the Holy Father and the Magisterium. Similar to what your narrator is doing in this video.   It wasn't Vatican II that was the problem. It was the reactions on the two extreme sides.  The left who wanted to liberalize everything and worse those on the extreme right who openly rejected the church's decisions. The biggest problem with Vatican two was how it was interpreted and the fact that groups on the so called far right like the St. Pius the X Society and likely yourselves denied the authority and authenticity of the Pope.  


I believe in Christ's words in Matthew's Gospel He was talking to the far right in particular.  I am certain you would not recognize Jesus if He was standing in your midst.  I recall what Jesus said and I believe He said it.  You may find yourselves receiving this same response for the harm you are causing.  St. Paul would never support what you are doing on your website either…. Regardless, the truth is you are attaching disciples of Jesus.  Appointing yourselves as the head.


Your arrogance and self righteousness will likely lead you into Hell…. We have both the Novas Ordo and Tridentine Mass at my parish in Toronto Canada every day…I learned the most important lesson early in my conversion.  Obedience unless I am being led into Sin.  The Novas Ordo Mass is not Sinful.  I know all the 11 priests at my parish  prefer to say the Tridentine Mass, yet they offer both.  Popes Benedict XVI, John Paul I and II, Paul VI and John XXIII were not Heretics.  I encourage you all to repent and stop the scandal.  You are sinning gravely and will be held accountable by Our Lord Jesus Christ.  I am praying for your conversion and will include you in my daily recitation of the Divine Mercy Chaplet and Rosary.


Leeda Crawford

Toronto, ON


MHFM: Let us tell you what we know: you are without any doubt on the road to Hell.  You defend heretics who deny Catholic teaching.  You reject the Catholic faith and the facts in front of you.  You are a liar.  Indeed, you are so remarkably blind that while you hurl your truly worthless condemnations and anathemas, you fail to recognize that the Counter Church to which you belong esteems non-Christian religions which reject Jesus Christ.  In fact, here’s just one quote from Antipope Benedict XVI on that very point:


Benedict XVI, Catechesis, August 24, 2005: “This year is also the 40th anniversary of the conciliar Declaration Nostra Aetate, which has ushered in a new season of dialogue and spiritual solidarity between Jews and Christians, as well as esteem for the other great religious traditions.  Islam occupies a special place among them.” (L’Osservatore Romano, August 31, 2005, p. 11.)


That’s apostasy, in case you didn’t know.  Of course, you also ignore the fact that Benedict XVI has rejected the condemnations issued by the Catholic Church against heretics (e.g., by agreeing with the Lutherans on Justification contrary to the teaching of the Council of Trent, and by declaring that the schismatic ‘Orthodox’ need not accept Vatican I).  That’s a mortal sin, which you defend.  Wake up, you dishonest heretic.


Despite your complaints, the facts covered in the video on his book The Infancy Narratives do prove (to a person of good will) that Benedict XVI denied Catholic teaching on Scripture.  But we have a whole file documenting his almost countless heresies on many topics:  Benedict XVI (The Heresies of Benedict XVI File) [link to section].


You don’t understand obedience.  Your false notion of it is leading you into mortal sin and apostasy.  True obedience to God, the Catholic Church and the Papacy involves adhering faithfully and without compromise to traditional Catholic teaching and dogma.  Traditional Catholic teaching requires Catholics to reject as non-Catholics anyone (e.g., Benedict XVI) who rejects the teaching of the Catholic Church, even if that person purports to be a priest, a bishop or a ‘pope.’  See Galatians 1:8-9 on that point as well.  That’s Catholic teaching.  People who depart from the rule of faith lose membership in the Church, even if they usurp external positions of authority or dress up in Catholic robes.  But you are so dishonest that you haven’t even realized that Benedict XVI, etc. have completely departed from Catholic teaching.


Since you are not a Catholic and you are a liar, your prayers aren’t pleasing to God.  He rejects you.  Your attendance at the invalid Novus Ordo or even at a Tridentine Mass won’t help you.  It doesn’t please God at all.  That’s because you don’t have the Catholic faith; you bear false witness; and you defend the enemies of Catholic teaching.  Your prayers won’t be heard unless you pray in humility to embrace the truth and come out of your fog.  You are currently an enemy of God and the Catholic faith.  There’s no doubt about that.


By the way, here’s another article on Benedict XVI’s book series, Jesus of Nazareth.  This one proves that in just one book Benedict XVI denies the historical accuracy of Matthew’s Gospel, rejects the conversion of Jews, and teaches faith alone, just to name a few: The Massive Heresies in Benedict XVI's 2011 book, Jesus of Nazareth - Holy Week.  These facts are available for honest people of good will to recognize.  Unfortunately, that doesn’t include you at this time. 






I am a 59 year old lapsed Roman Catholic.  I have been angry and saddened by Catholicism for years now, by feel good Catholicism.  I rarely go to mass, and when I do I feel angry and empty afterwards.


Yesterday, I stumbled upon your Youtube site.  You guys have done wonders in restoring a sense of peace and reality into my life.  I have been soaking in your commentaries.


One question, I did some research on Most Holy Family Monastery, and the Southern Poverty Law Center classifies you as a "hate group."  Why?  I have screened over half a dozen of your videos, and have not heard anything hateful.  What is their reason for classifying you as a "hate group?"



David Gorczyca


MHFM: We’re glad to hear that you came across the material.  It’s crucial that you continue to consult the information and become fully convinced of traditional Catholic teaching.  From your comments it seems as if you attend the New Mass on occasion.  In reviewing the material, you will see that the New Mass is a non-Catholic service that must be avoided.  You should pray the Rosary each day and the Hail Mary frequently.  These steps cover how to return to the Catholic faith.  When you are convinced on the issues, we can help you with where to make a confession.


The Steps to convert to the traditional Catholic faith and for those leaving the New Mass - Baptism and Conditional Baptism - the Council of Trent's Profession of Faith for Converts


With regard to the Southern Poverty Law Center, they classify anyone who adheres to traditional Catholic teaching (e.g., against homosexuality, etc.) and opposes a liberal world view as a ‘hate group.’  It’s ridiculous and outrageous.  They are a joke.




I'm listening to your debate with Keith Thompson on Justification… Listening to that false-Christian leader feels like one is listening to a devil.  If it weren't for your excellent Biblical refutations, which highlight the immutable omnipotence of the Church against all heresies, who could endure it?!  You effectively demolished his so-called argument - lie-by-lie - with your truth-upon-truth, infallible, Biblical, Traditional Catholic (Christian) doctrines… thank you!


Justification Debate




I just watched your "Is the world about to end" video, and I must say I'm fascinated…


Many thanks, God bless





Dear Brothers,

Thank you for the article recommending the interesting video about the man's amazing mental ability that disproves evolution.  As you said, it shows the amazing power and potential of the human mind. It reminds one of what the intelligence of angels might be like. One cannot even begin to imagine the infinite length, breadth and width of God's intelligence.  It is sad to see so many people throw away their souls so recklessly in the face of such an awe inspiring Creator.  Daniel Tammet is living proof that evolution is a hoax. According to evolution, he should be a prime specimen, an "evolutionary leap."  Yet the reality is that he is handicapped ('autism').  It is the constant fact that any deviation from God's design results in an impaired, often dysfunctional organism.  His talent proves there is a Creator, disproves evolution and gives glory to God…  James 1:17 - "Every best gift, and every perfect gift, is from above, coming down from the Father of lights, with whom there is no change, nor shadow of alteration."

God Bless,


Mr. & Mrs. White




Dear Brothers:


Thank you for the video about Daniel Tammet and his exceptional ability, which is an astounding testimony to God's creative wisdom and a refutation of the evolution heresy. Sadly, Daniel's great gifts for mathematical computations and acquiring new languages are being, just like Mel Gibson's talents as a filmmaker, wasted, utterly wasted. Daniel's homosexuality leaves him in the darkness of sin and an enemy of the God who favored him so much, and headed for the furnace of hell…


Joseph Ramirez




Hello Brother, the other day I had some Jehovah's Witnesses come to my door. I did my best to defend the Catholic teaching, but after a while I started getting overwhelmed. The Witnesses spend a lot of time studying the bible and I am not as knowledgeable about it. I would like some help from you guys on how I can really refute their claims when they come to my door. Perhaps you could make a video on this? They just won't listen to the straight and simple answer that outside the Catholic Church there is no salvation. I would really appreciate the help.


God Bless



MHFM: This is a video we have on the issue: Quick Refutation of Jehovah’s Witnesses. 




Subject: Bad Will of the Lukewarm



Today I had an interesting text conversation with my cousin who lives in CA.  I live in FL.  I told her that Obama was visiting Orlando.  She responded by saying it was great and that I should tell people that I met Obama (I did not). I told her that I was not interested in meeting Obama.  She therefore thought that I was a republican.  I explained to her that I was neither a republican nor a democrat and I proceeded to tell her that the democratic party was very evil because of morality issues.  This led to the subject of abortion and homosexuality.  She claimed to be opposed to homosexuality and abortion except in cases of rape.  Of course even that is wrong but since she claimed to be opposed to it I asked her how she could in conscience, support the democratic party (which she does).  She responded by saying that she wants to change the subject.  I find this typical of people whose positions are in some way in conflict with the moral order.  They evade the subject.  This is actually their conscience at work.  In their mind they know their position is contrary to God's will and they cannot bear the thought so they evade the subject.  So she changed the subject.  Guess what she started to talk about?  Since we were talking about moral issues she stated that "Pope Francis and Benedict are good but John Paul II was the best"!  Naturally I had to explain to her that they were manifest heretics and heretical antipopes.  She did not even know what I meant by "manifest heretics".  I sent her a link to your website with pictures of John Paul II's various acts of apostasy.  I then told her she needs to realize that we are living in the end times.  Her only response was "ok".  There she goes evading the subject again.  I hope she looks through your website thoroughly…





The article about the Tammet’s extraordinary mental abilities was very interesting. Especially the part about "number 6".  "...This does ring true on a number of levels.  As numbers appear in his mind as diverse images and shapes, the number he likes least is the number “6”.  He says: “6 is the number I find hardest to experience in any sort of meaningful visual way.  It’s often the absence of anything.  It’s like a hole, or a chasm, like a black hole....."




Dear Brothers,


Interesting video on man's amazing mental ability.  The mind is truly the key to the universe and it is God's decision who will receive the gift of knowledge and wisdom…


The true gift of knowledge and wisdom as we know it, is the gift of faith as explained in the Bible, especially Hebrews 11:1-40. These time-honored amazing tasks carried out by lowly people are all accredited to God, not evolution.  What is amazing to me is that Kim Peek "the rain man" could recite the bible and most of the dates in history, though he could not put 2+2 together to figure out that there is no salvation outside the Catholic Faith (without the Grace of God)… As mentioned before; so many in the world want to understand before believing, where the true believer, believes in order that he/she may understand. 


Tom Miles




Dear brothers Dimond,

I am the biggest fan of your site and you are the only preachers I fully, 100 percent, trust. I am not baptized, but I like to be baptized in the Traditional Catholic church.

Do you have any contacts in the Netherlands?...

Please keep up your mission of truth.

God bless you!




MHFM: Thanks for the interest.  It’s crucial that you follow through with your intention to convert.  You should follow these steps:


The Steps to convert to the traditional Catholic faith and for those leaving the New Mass - Baptism and Conditional Baptism - the Council of Trent's Profession of Faith for Converts


When there isn’t a traditional Catholic who can perform the baptism for you, then a non-Catholic can do it.  The person should obviously be someone who will observe the basic matter and form.  He must also possess the minimal intention.  We recommend that you pray the Rosary each day, and get into the habit of praying the Hail Mary frequently.




Dear Brothers,


The video on Man`s Amazing Mental Ability Disproves Evolution is most interesting, these phenomenon cases are worthy and revealing.


After I came across your site and learned what happened to the Catholic Church I also came across an SSPX “Traditional” site in Portugal, although I had heard one time or other the name Lefebvre mentioned in the news I was not familiar at all with this group but I then became curious and wanted to understand their ideas so I searched their site and found that they were very much against the Vatican II false Council with its innovations in particular the new Mass, ordinations and others but at the same time they would publish pictures of  the last anti-popes who were the main causes of  the Vatican  revolution, and on top of it they defend them in their perverse teachings as if nothing had happened…. how fake they are,  I sent them an e-mail at that time calling their attention  to their inconsistent material and that it was true madness for anyone to disagree on the one hand with the dirty revolution and making the Sacraments void and at the same time sticking to these foreigners to the faith, I asked them why they did not take the sedevacantist position and of course they answered that it was crazy to take such position. Once they consider themselves traditionalists I am sure they are aware that the Catholic Church and its true Popes have through times condemned all modernism and that heretics and apostates are ipso facto outside and are not part of the Catholic Church, so why should they be against sedevacantism – the Chair of Peter is Empty, no doubt, the mystery of iniquity at work…


The traditional Catholic Church has always been known by its four marks, One, Holy, Catholic and Apostolic, the One Church of the Faithful but during my time in the Novus Ordo Church I became aware of various existing movements… I found it somewhat strange that these religious organizations had different doctrines within each one, one movement would persist mainly on the Holy Spirit and would dance away just like the protestants do, the other movement would teach that Jesus Christ was not present in the Eucharist and that it was just a symbol, they taught that it was not necessary to confess one´s sins to a “priest” because he was just a man and etc… what confusion, what have they done???… Evil, evil nothing but evil.


Your work is much appreciated,




In J.M.J

M.Fernanda da Silva




Subject: Your Article


Dear Brothers,

Your article about the man with the amazing brain blew my mind.  There were some deep mysteries you shed light on… Thanks for the article, Brothers, and God bless your work.

May Our Lady keep us,
Mario Chavez




Subject: Mel Gibson

Dear Brothers,

Thank you for the comments about Mel Gibson. His apostasy is truly astounding and outrageous. It is disgusting. His rejection of the dogma, Outside the Catholic Church there is no Salvation, shows its demonic consequences. As you said, he worships his previous fame and fortune, and is willing to essentially sell his soul in an attempt to return to “the good graces” of Hollywood. Also, the totally false rumour that Mel either agrees with or has helped (or visited) Most Holy Family Monastery is diabolical.  I even heard some years ago that Mel Gibson had visited MHFM, and logically concluded that he must have donated a large sum (small for him) to the Monastery. Also, shockingly, someone wrote the following comments to an article online about Mel Gibson and MHFM: "Mel Gibson is a big liar and Judaizer! I saw him go into the infamous "Most Holy Family Monastery" and he received the Sacraments from some sketchy schismatic bishop (Malachi Martin)? That Monastery is run by a... son of a Jewish Rabbi." This is the most extraordinary and outrageous Satanic calumny and slander.
It is these sorts of lies that false traditionalists believe without thinking or fact-checking any of the stories…

God Bless,

Mr. & Mrs. White




I have seen many of your videos on Youtube and am convinced that the Vatican 2 "Catholics" are in fact heretics.  I have been concerned about attending the Mass and receiving confession. In the wake of the post-conciliar Novus Ordo religion, finding a valid priest is difficult… What should I do?

God bless you,


MHFM: Thanks for the interest.  It's important to realize the situation today (during the Great Apostasy).  It is one in which basically all the churches are either heretical Vatican II churches or “traditionalist” churches where the priest is heretical in some way.  Thus, there aren't any churches that are fully Catholic, where one can join, regard the priest as Catholic and support the church.  However, there are some options for receiving the sacraments of confession (which is obviously crucial) and possibly the Eucharist (in a traditional rite only) depending upon where one lives.  Once a person is convinced on all the issues we can help him or her with options.   


Before receiving sacraments, one must reach the point where one is committed never to attend the New Mass again, believes in Outside the Church There is No Salvation without exception (no “baptism of desire,” no salvation for those “invincibly ignorant” of the Catholic faith), rejects NFP, won’t support any heretical priests, etc.  That’s explained in this file: Where to go to Mass or confession today?  People should also make the traditional profession of faith from the Council of Trent, which can be accessed from the aforementioned file.  Further, it should be understood that the priests who were ordained in The New Rite of Ordination [PDF File] were not validly ordained.  Since “priests” ordained in the New Rite of Ordination are invalid, any mortal sins confessed to such “priests” must be confessed again to a valid priest once a person is prepared for confession.  We also recommend people to pray the Rosary each day, all 15 decades if possible.




Subject: False Rumors


Dear Brothers,

Thank you for your post regarding Mel Gibson's shameful apostasy. I read with sadness about the false rumors among "traditional Catholics" that Mr. Gibson gave some kind of financial support to your monastery. Satan, who is so full of hatred for Jesus Christ, has clearly been whispering into the hearts of these false Catholics in an attempt to destroy your most important apostolate. Thanks be to God, you have done an amazing job with what little funding you do receive, but, as you point out, "The truth is that if we received anywhere near  the funds that are routinely given to (and completely and diabolically wasted on) many heretical false traditionalist groups, the impact we could have would be even greater."

Your example of the $300,000 funding false traditionalist Fisher-More College received in a single week for their heretical efforts was really shameful. Yes, it's a diabolical waste. You said MHFM would be happy to receive that over the course of a few years!

I'm glad you posted this. It made me realize just how necessary even the smallest donations are that you receive. 





Dear Brothers,


I feel that Mel Gibson should be pitied more than scorned.  The devil has not been happy with him since his making of The Passion of The Christ and has done a real number on him.  He was easy prey for the devil due to Mel suffering from alcoholism.  I pray every day for Mel, and I'm requesting that everyone does the same.   With everyone's prayers, I have complete confidence that God will set Mel back on the right track.  As written on the entrance of Our Lady of Lourdes Hospital in my area.......The body is often curable....The soul is ever so.  So, please, please, please, pray for Mel.  He really needs our prayers.  


Thank you for all of your hard work in defending the One, Holy, Catholic and Apostolic Church.  


Mary Theresa


MHFM: No, he should not be pitied.  He’s a total disgrace, and his problems are his fault.  It’s also not clear that in his adult years he was ever a true Catholic who actually had the faith, and he’s certainly not one now.  His problems are: a lack of faith and bad will.


Also, people don’t ‘suffer’ from alcoholism.  They choose to be alcoholics.  It’s not a disease.  It’s a mortal sin.




Subject: Stunning debate


Hello, dear Brothers,


Your debate with Steve: "Do 'Baptism of Desire' Traditionalist Priests Believe Souls Can Be Saved In False Religions" is stunning!... He at one point said the words, "I make it very clear"--the only thing he makes clear is that he doesn't know how to tell the truth. Oh, you just told him "the only thing you make clear is that you contradict yourself"! Thank you!  Earlier in the debate he said non-Catholics or 'Jews' could be saved "in a way we don't understand" and "that's the mystery of baptism of desire"!  This is almost unbelievable.


And why do these salvation heretics always bring up Saint Paul before his conversion as something they think supports their false argument when it doesn't?  His lack of conviction is astonishing: he admits to the statements you read to him from the heretical priests as being heretical, but later he defends that same priest claiming that maybe he was misunderstood, or simply said it wrong, or didn't mean what he wrote/said, or the big one: but he told me he accepts all Catholic dogma, etc.


I hope this man listened to the debate afterward so he could hear himself flip-flopping like a politician in the hot seat -- you never got a straight answer to your valid questions.  What am I saying?  He's a liar - he'll just continue to defend his own and his heretical priests' false beliefs no matter how many lies he has to tell.


Why do people resist the truth?! Haven't they figured out by now that nothing can compare with God's truth?  Thank you for telling him at the end that he's possessed, for he surely is…


New Article


MHFM: This is a new article on a very interesting video.


48 minute video: Man’s Amazing Mental Ability Disproves Evolution




Subject: Atheists




It's clear that atheists are not really atheists in the way they define it. It's not that they don't believe in God, but unfortunately, it's the case where they hate Him. If they truly believed God didn't exist, then why all the hate? You can't hate what doesn't exist, right? If you listen to how atheists speak about God, it is horrible. Rather than just being like, "well the misery in the world is because God doesn't exist", what they sadly do is say to people who believe in God: "your God has people suffering in the world" etc. Their words betray them. They are HATEFUL THEISTS. Just an observation I made which indeed lines up with Sacred Scripture and the Popes.



Melina Wisky.




Subject: Cosmos mini-series


Tonight's episode of the mini-series was completely hostile and belligerent towards religion.  Neil DeGrasse Tyson, the host, made it clear that he believed that neither DNA, nor the human eye, nor any life at all was intelligently designed.  He made the claim that evolution is not just a theory anymore than the theory of gravity is just a theory, that it is a scientific fact.  That it "happened".  But it did not happen.  It is a fairytale. They have no way of proving any of this stuff.  But it is presented as fact. 


As MHFM has said, DNA is like a coded language and it is like it was intelligently designed.  It is too bad some gullible people might see the show and lose their faith assuming it to all be true.  How do evolutionists explain the uniqueness of human beings?  Shouldn't any OTHER creature have at some time, ever evolved to anywhere near our level of intelligence and civilization building and TALKING? 


But here is the kicker: Tyson said he viewed his understanding of evolution and the connection of all life as a 'spiritual experience'.  I'm not surprised, since evolution is a religion.  It is a pagan religion and a dangerous pagan religion. It is made up! Yes, DeGrasse Tyson can make his case for evolution, it can sound convincing and plausible to many, but that doesn't make it true.  It is just another man-made pagan religion that evil people… choose to believe because of their diabolical lifestyles.  They don't want there to be a God so they can enjoy their sinful behavior…


Sincerely, Michael Rudnicki




Subject: SSPX Seminary


Dear Brothers,

Thank you for the article about the SSPX's heretical new seminary.  According to one source, the total cost is estimated to be about $40 million.  It is a truly diabolical waste of money.  It is a gigantic monument to the Vatican II Great Apostasy, since as you wrote, the SSPX teaches numerous absurd heresies, such as that souls can be saved in any religion, that the Catholic Church has defected, that the Magisterium contradicts itself, that people who don't have the Catholic faith are in the Catholic Church, that it is 'Catholic' to operate schismatically, and that people like Francis (who deny the true faith in many ways) have the true faith.  The obstinate supporters of the SSPX are like people who go to harlots - they pay to commit spiritual fornication.  No doubt that for many of such brain-dead fools, the new seminary will serve to further confirm them in the lie and delusion that there will be some kind of "restoration of the Church," that Rome will convert back to Tradition, and that everyone will live happily ever after, just like in the fairy tales - the Disneyland seminary.  It is outrageous and tragic.  They refuse to accept the truth that this is the Great Apostasy, there is no pope, there is no salvation outside the Catholic Church, and our Lord Jesus Christ will return very, very soon to judge the living and the dead.

God Bless,

Mr. & Mrs. White


Outer Shell


Subject: Outer Shell




… I would like to add that we could say the evil SSPX, in their disgraceful wasting of their bad-willed adherents' savings accounts in order to build the "outer shell" of their pretentious "traditional Catholic" seminary, are clearly taking their cues from their "popes", John Paul II and Benedict XVI, both of whom, as your videos exposing them reveal, often wore the shell emblem on their vestments, indicating that they've accomplished their diabolical goal: their "church" is devoid of the Catholic Faith - it's just an empty or "outer shell".




Dear Brothers:


When I first read the news about Gibson, and then the latest on the other false traditionalists, the SSPX, I felt an overwhelming sense of sadness.  Still do.  But it's a sadness that I think I should always feel, and will always try to remember.  These notices, especially appearing back-to-back, really drive home the enormity of the Apostasy, and the littleness of the Remnant.  We must consider, too, that when Our Lord was experiencing His Agony in the Garden (and His agony throughout His Passion), these apostate end-times would have been in His thoughts (as no doubt were the millions who would reject Christ and His one true Church over the centuries).  And yet, we also have so very much to be thankful for.  God knew His revelations and warnings about the end-times would mostly fall on deaf ears precisely when an understanding of such prophecies would be needed the most, and precisely when (by their fulfillment) the prophecies could be understood by men.   Yet, even knowing they would be ignored and rejected by almost everyone, God revealed those prophecies anyway for the benefit of the few.  Who can even begin to imagine all the good things God has done for us -- and to think of the little He asks in return. 


But what He asks is apparently too much for Gibson and so many like him who prefer to be applauded by the enemies of Christ.  These fools do not see that they are indeed giving their performances:  they are unwitting players in Satan's final production of Non Serviam.  Isn't it ironic that, since the rise of Protestantism, heretics have called the Catholic Church "the Whore of Babylon".  But in these last days, heretics like the SSPX and the rest of the false Catholics, insist upon calling the Whore of Babylon "the Catholic Church".   How like Satan and his penchant for inversion.


Lee Ann 




… I'm listening to your youtube channel discussion, Another Dishonest 'Baptism of Desire' Supporter.  Around the 13:50 mark, after you told the individual that the CMRI priests are all [salvation] heretics, the caller responded "But it's kind of like saying a person that commits murder....can they be saved? ..."  This individual was objecting to what he perceived as your comparing the mortal sin of the belief and teaching of 'baptism of desire' to the mortal sin of murder, even though you didn't actually use those words - you didn't need to.  The reason he perceived it is because the heretical teaching of 'baptism of desire' IS murder - of the worst kind:  HERESY - and in his heart he knew it, after hearing you reiterate the solemn teachings of the Church and warn him about the wolves in priests' clothing.  BUT, as usual for these persons, the individual chose diabolical disoriented disagreement over truth…


… I also listened to you trying to help Another Dishonest, Heretical SSPX Supporter, in a video from over a year ago, so he and the rest of that obstinate liar's club have since undoubtedly sunk deeper into the dark abyss of heresy- if that is even possible, for he was not even a little bit honest in the discussion - which is why they have the heretical priests that they have and the heretical chapels and heretical seminaries and heretical books and more heresy and more heresy.  You really tried to help this individual, like you have so many, many others, but he loves heresy and one cannot convince such a person of the truth (as these discussions often demonstrate).  We appreciate your ongoing dedication and your making these discussions available for the education and edification of the good-willed.




Dear Brothers,


With the "canonization" farce of anti-Christ JPII coming up in one month… The VII is readying the christening of the ultimate "Trojan Horse".  JPII… tried to put himself on the same level as God, as JPII's motto "be not afraid" is taken from the time of Jesus' Transfiguration on the mountain (Matthew 17: 1-9).  JPII was on one of the seven hills of Rome and transfigured himself in order that the world should honor him as God…


Tom Miles




Subject: Article on the SSPX


Dear Brothers,


Thanks for the sincere and assertive article on the SSPX. It's interesting how the content of the newsletter captures two aspects that together makes a good metaphor of the SSPX: a huge sum of money to create an "outer shell", that is, a huge effort to create an external appearance of Catholicism.



Rafael Centeio


New Post on the SSPX


MHFM: This is a new post on the Society of St. Pius X.


The Society of St. Pius X (SSPX) to receive 7 million dollars for their heretical seminary project




Dear Brothers:


Thank you for the article and commentary regarding Mel Gibson. Talk about reaping what one has sown! His demise is a real tragedy, mainly because he seems to have never held the true Catholic faith, whole and inviolate, and therefore, his house is built on sand. It came crashing down with the fiascoes surrounding his divorce, his new union, his alcoholism, his public foul-mouthed tirades, and his overall disgrace. Now, in his heresy and apostasy, he is desperately trying to gain the favor of the Hollywood establishment, selling his soul to the Devil and placing himself on the fast track to hell… Your remarks about waste were absolutely right on. Now he courts the Christ-rejecters to reclaim some new image. Another house built on sand. May he convert before it's too late.


Joseph Ramirez


Mel Gibson


MHFM: In our view, it’s pretty obvious that Mel Gibson worships his previous fame and celebrity.  He is so desperate to regain his previous status as a major movie star that he’s willing to commit complete apostasy (and essentially sell his soul) in an attempt to return to “the good graces” of Hollywood.  It’s disgraceful and sad, for of course we desire his conversion and salvation.  The acts described in this piece are, in our view, clearly an appeal to the Hollywood power structure:


Mel Gibson’s amazing apostasy – He attends Shabbat dinners, Passover Seders, Rosh Hashanah and Yom Kippur dinners, donated millions to Jewish causes


Part of Mel’s problem is that he imbibed his heretical father’s salvation theology.  Mel’s diabolical father, Hutton, is a horrible heretic.  He’s a vicious opponent of the water baptism dogma.  Like all ‘BOD’ supporters in our day, he believes that souls can be saved in any religion.  He completely rejects the dogma Outside the Church There is No Salvation as it has been defined.  That false theology impacts how they look at everything.


There have also been persistent rumors among ‘traditional Catholics’ for approximately the last 15 years that Mel Gibson gave financial support of some kind to Most Holy Family Monastery.  They are not true.  Neither Mel Gibson nor his father has ever donated anything in any form to the monastery.  Part of the reason for those rumors is that Mel Gibson named his chapel Holy Family Church.  As a result, some people erroneously concluded that Gibson’s Holy Family Church was connected to or supportive of Most Holy Family Monastery in some way.  It’s not the case.  Over the years we’ve also been asked to forward messages to Mel Gibson, as if we have some affiliation with him.  This is another example of how people will spread things around without checking the facts or confirming whether they are accurate.  It’s actually amazing how little concern for truth many ‘traditionalists’ exhibit in such matters.  Indeed, the appalling dishonesty they exhibit in those areas is comparable to and often worse than typical pagans.  (And we’ve been on the receiving end of such damaging lies more than any other group in the ‘traditional’ movement by far.)


Perhaps another reason people falsely concluded that there was some affiliation is that we’ve done aggressive advertising campaigns on television, radio and the internet, in a way that far exceeds any other group in the world that purports to be Catholic.  Some erroneously assumed, therefore, that Mel Gibson must have funded the effort.  But that’s not the case.  It’s rather that we aggressively use donations and resources we have to spread our message (the true Catholic faith) and reach new people.  The truth is that if we received anywhere near the funds that are routinely given to (and completely and diabolically wasted on) many heretical false traditionalist groups, the impact we could have would even be much greater.  As an example of such appalling and diabolical waste, the aforementioned false traditionalist college, Fisher-More College, raised approximately $300,000 in about a single week for their heretical efforts.  (We’d be happy to receive that over the course of a few years.)  As we previously posted, their apostate ‘bishop’ forbade those false traditionalists from having their ‘Latin Mass’ at the college, in a striking example of JUSTICE and what we pointed out concerning false traditionalists reaping exactly what they have sown.


Fisher-More College Forbidden to Offer ‘Latin Mass’


The waste on that heretical college is by no means the only example of such appalling waste on heresy, lies, falsehood and evil.  Examples could be multiplied for quite a while.  They include seemingly endless donations to apostate ‘priests’ who claim to spread the Message of Fatima; support for the SSPX (a completely heretical group whose theological positions are beyond absurd); funding for sedevacantist priests and communities which hold that souls can be saved without the Catholic faith and in false religions; and many others.




Subject: Alcoholics


Hello Brothers,

I listened with great interest, to your video on why addicts and alcoholics relapse. I am a recovering alcoholic with 20 yrs sobriety. I am a traditional Catholic going on 7 yrs. My father died of alcoholism at 54yrs, and my 2 brothers and 2 sisters are alcoholics. My one sister who attends the Novus Ordo Mass was sober for about 10 yrs, but has relapsed. I truly believe that it is only by the grace of God that I remain sober to this day, and have no desire to go back to drinking at all.  I am horrified by the thought of demons controlling my family, but I know the best thing I can do for them now is pray. Keep up the good work!



Why Drug Addicts and Alcoholics So Frequently Relapse


“Catholic” Teachers Association


Just one more data-point.  One can only surmise that "Who am I to judge", "Don't call me pope", Franny approves.


Ontario “Catholic” teachers association to march in gay WorldPride parade in Toronto




Bill Mulligan


The SSPX lady


Subject: The SSPX lady


Dear Brothers:


It is very interesting (and telling) that the SSPX lady who visited Shawna would have to ask:  "but where did these monks get this info from".  That she was unable to recognize and appreciate the truth she was hearing is yet another proof that unless the true faith is held whole and inviolate, it is not held at all.  Both explicitly and implicitly, the bishops/priests of the SSPX have taught their followers that the dogmas pronounced by the true popes are meaningless -- that one can't accept them and one can't believe them, and said followers have learned this diabolical lesson well.  These people have replaced the dogmas of the Church with the teachings of Lefebvre (who also rejected papal teachings).  In cult-like fashion, they adore him and their other SSPX leaders as "saviors".   Some of them have actually called Lefebvre "infallible" and certainly he is idolized as such.  As these deluded people see it, the true popes are not infallible but Lefebvre is.  This is idolatry and Protestantism.   In addition to rejecting the Catholic dogma that there is no salvation outside the Catholic Church, the followers of the SSPX have also rejected the papacy and therefore (like the protestants they are), they cannot distinguish between a true pope and an antipope.  Their pretention to "tradition", as Shawna noted, is nothing more than devotion to externals bereft of meaning.  Sadly, the SSPX is nothing more than the nostalgia wing of the Vatican 2 sect. 


Lee Ann


Patrick Madrid


Subject: Patrick Madrid calls sedevacantists "sad conspiracy theorists"


Hello again MHFM and Brothers,


Every now and then I flip by the EWTN radio station in my car on my drive home form work. Heretic, Patrick Madrid, has a program… He has been mentioned on some of the videos on your website also. His answers to people who call his show are even more liberal than the Vatican II catechism they sell in all "Catholic" book stores. On yesterday's show 3/10/14, a caller asked Madrid about some Sedevacantist YouTube videos (probably your videos!) and what he thought of the Sedevacantist position. Madrid said Sedevacantists were "sad conspiracy theorists". His pathetic arguments against Sedevacantism included the "gates of hell shall not prevail against the church" argument and how Sedevacantism would make Jesus a liar; also the argument that if there are no validly elected cardinals, there can never again be a true pope in Rome. The poor guy who called in to the radio show was on the fence about Sedevacantism and Madrid just shoved him over to the Vatican II sect side. What is ironic is that later in the show, after Madrid defended liberalism and Vatican II, a caller asked about godparents, Madrid vehemently insisted that both godparents had to be Catholic. What is truly sad is how Madrid takes conservative positions on small issues and completely misses the big picture.




MHFM: That’s interesting.  Thanks for the e-mail.  We have a video dedicated to him.  It’s revealing. 


Patrick Madrid’s Jaw-Dropping Heresy [video]


While we hope for his conversion, Madrid is a complete apostate who accepts false ecumenism and the heresies of Vatican II.  The video (linked to above) shows that Madrid even regards super-obstinate, viciously anti-Catholic Protestants as “members of the Body of Christ”!  He said this about one anti-Catholic Protestant who attacks the Papacy, the Eucharist, the priesthood, Marian dogmas, and believes that every single prayer to Mary is an act of idolatry.  Such a man is a “member of the Body of Christ,” according to Patrick Madrid.  What incredible apostasy.  Obviously his position repudiates Catholic teaching.  It’s satanic, actually. 


The video also exposes an argument Madrid published in an attempt to defend Vatican II’s teaching on religious liberty.  The video addresses what Madrid published and completely refutes it.  It shows that Madrid doesn’t even understand Catholic teaching on religious liberty.  (The same is true of many other V-2 apologists who promote a similar argument.) 


What’s very interesting, however, is that the video currently has over 26,000 views, with 121 YouTube ‘likes’ and 223 YouTube ‘dislikes.’  It thus has almost twice as many ‘dislikes’ as ‘likes.’  Think about that.  Presumably many of those ‘dislikes’ come from people who purport to be Catholic, and possibly even ‘conservative Catholics.’  So many of those ‘disliking’ the video also consider themselves faithful to Catholic teaching.  But when they ‘dislike’ the video, they are actually agreeing with Patrick Madrid that viciously anti-Catholic Protestants (who denounce prayer to Mary as idolatry) are “members of the Body of Christ”; for they are officially noting their disapproval of a video that denounces him for teaching such a heresy.  Their bad will is astounding. 


Actually, they are brain-dead fools and deserve to be considered such.  For although they are not fools as result of an innate defect, they become mindless morons (who publicly attack what actually defends the faith they claim to hold) through astounding bad will and hatred of the truth.  Since they don’t care about the facts or the truth, they render themselves essentially brain-dead.  Consistency with Catholic teaching or embracing that which is just is not their priority.  No, they just go with the flow, defend their heretical friends/groups, dislike the video, and walk the path to Hell.


For example, when such people (barring a conversion) go to their judgments, God could say:  A man obstinately held and promoted that every prayer to Mary is an act of idolatry, that the Holy Sacrifice of the Mass is blasphemy, and that it’s an anti-Christian myth to believe I gave St. Peter authority over the Church.  Contrary to My teaching, you believed and promoted that such a man is a member of My Church; for when a video denounced someone for teaching that he is a member of My Church, you made your dislike of the video public.  Begone, to the everlasting fire. 


Near Death Deceptions?


Subject: Near Death Deceptions?


Brothers Dimond,

Perusing YouTube, I found many posts of "near death experiences". The videos of people having temporarily died, claiming to have experienced or having been shown heaven and/or hell are particularly captivating. Having watched many of them, so far all of these people accept "Christ" after these experiences. However, it's always a protestant or non-catholic "Christ" they profess and adhere to. I know this because they assert sola fidé and sola scriptura rhetoric exclusively in the outcomes of these stories. Perhaps there is one where the person turns to the true Christ of the Catholic church but I doubt I'll find one.
     I can't help but believe this is a trick from Satan's handbag where we find UFO phenomena, ghost stories, false Marian apparitions, deceiving signs and wonders, etc. outside of the VII counterfeit church deception, this has to be high on the list of his most powerful deceptions in use today. These stories are so scary and emotionally moving. Jesus, Angels, vivid portrayals of heaven (never a sighting of Mary, btw) all the feelings they remember and convey to the audience... All of these things, along with their sincerity leaves little room for doubt in the viewer that their experience was real. But most if not all these folks turn into powerful lures to the public for the non-catholic, heretical churches out there. The most diabolical trap to get out of is one where you believe on your soul something is of Jesus but is truly Satan with a mask. You would defend this "truth" and this "Christ" with everything you had, so you do the dirty work for him by keeping yourself enslaved. All he had to do was put on the show for you - a neat vision, a vivid experience, whatever it takes to ingest the diabolical, death-dealing poisonous doctrine he's designed in it, namely, finding Christ anywhere other than the Catholic Church.  Your thoughts?


MHFM: Yes, it is a major deception.  Almost all of those experiences are from Satan.  The goals of such a deception are to convince people of the following lies: that there is salvation outside of Christ and His one true Church; that many are saved, instead of few; and that people can be saved without observing what Christ commanded, in faith and morality. 


By convincing people of these lies, the Devil keeps millions on the path to Hell, with hope in a false salvation message.  Unless someone is researching such videos to refute them, one should not watch them.




Subject: Some thoughts on heretics…


Dear Brothers, 


It really disgusts me that many SSPX... smugly affirm that such insulting people, such as a Muslim or Jew, might, one day, rejoice amidst the song of Angels (without converting).  Oh .... what lying hypocrites.  To reject Jesus as God is to blaspheme Mother Mary's Divine Maternity.  And to 'top it off', these SSPX'ers join pathetic 'resistance groups' and feel quite prideful they are pleasing God.  How wrong they are.  The only thing these 'resistant groups' resist is infallible dogma and Jesus' works of mercy, hereby decreeing them in full communion with the devil.  


Their love of externals is unspeakably appalling.  For example, there is an SSPX lady who visited our house to watch various Catholic videos.  She found nothing wrong with the material.  It sounded promising.  However, what caught my attention is her loyal focus on externals.  Almost every time she visited, she made sure we were modesty dressed, wearing scapulars.... etc.  I strongly felt she was basing her opinion on the material according to how WE looked, as opposed to reading and loving truth.  Surely, if she drank truth like she does silly externals, she wouldn't care if we were wearing scapulars, which, by the way, do not guarantee one's place in Heaven.  Another indication this lady is fixed to externals is her concerned question, "Then where do you go for sacraments?"  I refused to answer, claiming one must have faith before approaching the sacraments… I hardly doubt this lady refrained from Communion since our meetings.  That alone will be a grim roadblock to her salvation.  If she calls again to meet, I'm going to tell her to stay home and do her homework (unless, of course, she takes a positive step and invites a family member).  I sincerely hope she converts, but fear that, one day, God will get sick of waiting for her.  And then for the rest of eternity, she will bewail her great love of man and asking advice of heretical priests.  Oh yeah, and when reviewing various Catholic dogmas, she asked, "But where did these monks get this information from?"  Such a question indicates that if someone were to arise from the dead and proclaim truth to her, she'd still be confused and hence, 'fair game' for Satan,




Francis & Civil Unions


Subject: Francis & Civil Unions


Dear Brothers,

Thank you for posting the article about Francis suggesting the "Church" could tolerate some "civil unions." It shows again the horrible consequences of the Vatican II apostasy. Francis said that moves to "regulate diverse situations of cohabitation (are) driven by the need to regulate economic aspects among persons, as for instance to assure medical care." It is astounding heresy. According to Francis, couples can fornicate, commit adultery, or even sodomy in order to "regulate economic aspects among persons." It is more evidence that he is an antipope, who clearly lacks any supernatural light of the Catholic faith. Matrimony is a sacrament, and it is not a business contract, but a vow 'until death do we part.' Matrimony should reflect the Lord Jesus Christ's relationship with the Catholic Church, the Immaculate Bride of Christ. For Francis the "Church" is a harlot, riding a Beast - just business as usual for Francis. The Annulment Fiasco – The Vatican II
Sect’s De Facto acceptance of Divorce and Remarriage - www.mostholyfamilymonastery.com/28_Annulments.pdf

God Bless,

Mr. & Mrs. White




MHFM: We hope to have some new videos coming soon.


“BOD” and “BOB” Refuted


Subject: BOD and BOB Refuted


I just wanted to thank you and point others to your complete and precise refutation of BOB and BOD on DVD and in other written work. Every time I listen to your refutation on the DVD on Various Catholic Issues and Many Other Topics- “Baptism of Desire” Buried, it leaves me in awe how wonderful and obviously, divinely inspired the magisterial teachings are which you used in your refutation. People who still believe in BOB and BOD really need to listen to this refutation.


I have read other articles on BOB and BOD from the other side attempting to make a case for these, but your refutation leaves no question as to how weak, evil and mischievous these attempts are. To believe in BOB and BOD, denies so much infallible magisterial teaching, that to hold these positions is simply to deny Christ's protection to His Church and the words of the Gospel that proclaim the infallible faith of St. Peter and his successors. Thank you so much, for your refutation which proclaims the enormous amount of work this represents and demonstrates your faithfulness to the true faith.


God be praised for infallible magisterial teachings,
Mary Jo Marceau-Hawthorne


“Baptism of Desire” Buried [video]


18 programs on 1 DVD on Various Catholic Issues and Many Other Topics


MHFM: Thanks for the interest.  In our day, it’s also true that only those who hold to the absolutely necessity of water baptism for salvation (i.e., no ‘baptism of desire’) believe in Catholic teaching on the necessity of Jesus Christ and the Catholic faith for salvation.




Subject: Dolan


Dear Brothers:


As you have pointed out, the mask has been torn off the apostate Vatican II sect. It's trying less and less to even appear somewhat Catholic. Case in point is the buffoon "Cardinal" Dolan and his praise for sodomite Michael Sam. Dolan's use of the word Bravo, a word used "to express approval when a performer or other person has done something well" is truly outrageous and disgusting. Anytime I've attended a performance by an orchestra or theatrical company, the word bravo was only uttered during a standing ovation at the end amid excited and approving applause. To think that a "prince" of the "church" is standing in rapturous applause, approval, and excitement for this diabolical activity just shows all the more that the Vatican II sect cannot possibly be the true Catholic Church, but is utterly false and of the Devil, and provoking divine vengeance.


Joseph Ramirez


Tim Dolan


Mr. Tim Dolan is evil and of Satan.   


From Mark V


"Cardinal" Tim Dolan says "Bravo!" to Michael Sam


MHFM: He really is an incredible apostate.  However, he’s the leader of the “Catholic Church” in NYC according to non-sedevacantists.  What a sick joke.




Subject: Bill Nye vs Ken Ham Debate


This is worth talking about because this Creationism debate at the Creation Museum (which Mr. Nye referred to only as a 'facility') was seen by hundreds of thousands if not over a million by now.  I did not get to see the whole debate, but it seems like Bro. Michael made more effective arguments in Creation and Miracles DVD, even with Catholic miracles left out…


Michael Rudnicki in Christ




Dear MHFM,


We live in the same school district as the boy who was suspended for making a pretend gun with his hand.


Last fall, our third grade son was suspended for three days.  Instead of cops and robbers or cowboys and Indians, kids of this generation play zombies/aliens and good guys, etc   My son was caught writing a "kill list" during library time, naming the other kids at school who were the zombies in the game. The principal understood that he was just playing and had absolutely no intention of causing real harm, but under the "zero-tolerance policy" and after a consultation with her supervisor, she had to suspend him with a level 2 infraction, violence.


(I have been checking your site daily since last April.  In January, I left the Novus Ordo, stopped using natural family planning, and am preparing to make the St. Louis de Montfort Consecration to Our Lady this Feast of the Annunciation… I think that the moment I started reading your information, I knew you were speaking the truth, but it was not easy for me to embrace and I still have doubts that I am going my own way.  So I have not yet received Holy Communion or Confession, because I am not 100% sure, but maybe 99.2%, something very close.  My hope is in Our Lady's guidance!  I would not be in this process of accepting that the True Church is in eclipse or be increasing devotion to Mary without your witness.)


God bless you.


MHFM: We’re glad that you have interest.  It’s obviously crucial that you become convinced on all the issues.  We recommend praying the full Rosary each day, and prayers for the gift of true supernatural faith.




Subject: Horrible


Dear Brothers,


I was horrified about this article, http://www.mostholyfamilymonastery.com/truthreport/woman-dies-attempting-home-abortion-drinking-vinegar/, because for one, concentrated vinegar is really toxic in large quantities. One has seen the use of vinegar to kill a goat and dress it in preparation for a feast. It is by far the most effective and fast. If her attempted abortion was also an attempted suicide then she accomplished both, sad to say. And it is as if your Catholic Spirituality section proves the point that it is “It is a dreadful thing to fall into the hands of the living God.” (Hebrews 10:31)


Sincerely and God speed,



Consecration of Russia


Would you all be able to tell me about the consecration of Russia as asked by Fatima?...


Bev, Wisconsin


MHFM: We have an article that covers that issue in detail.  We recommend that you read it: The Whole Truth about the Consecration and Conversion of Russia.


Also, this video contains a crucial overview of the Message of Fatima and the entire Vatican II Counter Church: The Third Secret of Fatima (3rd edition) [video].




Dear Brothers:


MHFM's exchange with the heretic Alvin is a picture worth a thousand words.  Alvin never quotes Catholic papal teaching but looks for men's "interpretations" here, there and everywhere -- and then picks the one that is most appealing to him!  Like the vast majority of people in the false sect, he asks the same question Pilate did before sentencing Christ to death:  what is truth?    Alvin and the other Vatican 2 adherents like him don't know what truth is and they couldn't care less.  In fact, they have a disgust for it.


Reading this exchange brought to my mind how, when I was in the V2 sect, I used to be confused by the fact that what I thought was the Catholic Church would often refer to itself as "the Vatican II church"(Of course, now I know why.)  Also, I used to be perplexed that, in official documents, you would never see quotes from popes from the past.  But it was especially troubling to me that statements made by Our Lord and recorded in Scripture were ignored and discarded as if they didn't exist.  Now, of course, I understand that the voice of the Groom (Our Lord) and the voice of the Bride (Holy Mother Church) would not be heard in this demonic, counterfeit church.   But what's really sad is that people like Alvin not only do not miss this Voice -- when they hear the truth, these fools attempt to contest it!  There is absolutely no difference between them and the protestant who calls himself a Christian but despises the dogmas of the Catholic Church.  If the mission of the Whore of Babylon was to go and remove from all nations every trace and remnant of Catholic truth, it can now rejoice with Antipope Francis:  Mission Accomplished.  


Lee Ann   




Subject: Alvin


Dear Brothers,

Thank you for posting the emails and your response to Alvin. It is ironic that Alvin falsely accuses true Catholics of being Protestants, when he doesn't even rely on Papal teaching for his beliefs. He admits he goes by the fallible (and heretical) opinions of priests: "I’ve heard three interpretations from priests so far." The dogma is the interpretation. There is no other "explaining" needed. As you said, just like the heretic he is, he struggles to answer your question directly.  He is a liar and so he tries to cover-up his abuse of the Truth. Alvin's position on salvation for non-Catholics is truly outrageous. According to him, human-sacrificing, blood-drinking, idolizing demon-worshipping pagans can be saved. He even puts Protestants (many of whom may be validly baptized) in the same category as pagans. It is astounding blindness. The first of the Ten Commandments states: "Thou shalt not have strange gods before me." (Ex. 20:3) It could not be clearer, yet for satanic fools like Alvin, worshipping the demons of hell is a way out of hell! What a truly sickening joke!!! That's Francis' and the Vatican II sect's religion; drunk on the blood of the Martyrs and the Saints.

God Bless,

Mr. & Mrs. White


Protestant Fiction


Dear MHFM,

I have been exchanging numerous emails with a Protestant that runs an anti-Catholic website… I linked to your… ‘Is the world about to End’ video, St. Malachy’s Prophecy, 3rd Secret of Fatima, the debate with the Calvinist heretic, the video on why rick Warren’s son found no purpose in life, creation and miracles past and present, etc and I even mentioned the names of the videos next to the links and the time duration and I also linked to the Refuting Protestant section etc so I really went out of my way for this Protestant as I do many other heretics both Novus Ordite and “traditional” etc. In the course of our exchanges I sent him this email below since he was citing for me “Revelation 18” when I had already destroyed his beliefs of sola scriptura by pointing him to the fact of the imperfection of the extant biblical manuscripts etc (I used quotes from your kjv video- especially the D.A Carson quotes) this devastated his entire confidence (it always does with all the Protestants I’ve interacted with) and he kept ignoring the fact and changing topics:


“… I do not believe in the Protestant literature. It is interesting that everything you say is based on your own thoughts and not facts or reality. This is called the subjectivist fallacy: “well this is true, because I think it is true.” Subjectivist fallacies and circular reasoning are in no way convincing to rational humanity.  You will reap what you have sown. You will realize how you lied, how you ignored what really mattered, how you downplayed the significance of the doctrinal offenses which now as we can see were quite important; how you didn’t value things of the faith, how you sugarcoated the truth in order to please friends and colleagues, how you were more concerned about externals than about substance, how you failed to accept and tell the truth as it is, and how you didn’t serve God alone. You will then realize that you acted in fraud, lived under a fraud, and perpetuated a fraud. You will accept your condemnation: but God gives you a foretaste of that now with all the disappointment that your deliberate self-deception brings (i.e, you know you are a heretic that worships a false god, does not have "scripture," and yet you persist in giving man made error filled books that status- this is idolatrous). It is a microcosm of what you will experience at your Judgment.


There is absolutely No Salvation Outside the Catholic Church www.vaticancatholic.com”.   The heretic then sent me the following ridiculous and laughable email with his Protestant fiction- and this type of desperate Protestant fiction is quite common when the heretics find themselves cornered:


"I'm afraid you are deceived!  Go follow the church that murders Bible believing Christians.  Go follow the church that sexually abuses LITTLE CHILDREN!!!  sexually abuses LITTLE CHILDREN!!  Did you get that??  Go follow the church that is full of homosexual pedophiles.  Go follow the church that worships Mary more than Jesus Christ our LORD AND SAVIOUR.  Go follow the church that bows down to idols.  Go follow the church that will lead you to the lake of fire and destruction.  Open your eyes!"


(I replied to the email by saying that the Church is perfect and showing how his false religion is filled with the pedophiles and sodomites- but I have not received a response yet):



Alvin the Heretic


MHFM: Below is an exchange with a heretic named Alvin.  Apparently Alvin viewed at least some of the information.  In his astounding bad will and blindness, he actually concluded that it’s Protestant.  The foolish heretic refuses to see that his sect is in communion with Protestants.  It teaches that Protestants don’t need conversion, that they’re in the Church, that their view of Justification is not condemned, etc.  Alvin wrote:


Hi brothers. I’ve done my best it’s up to Jesus now to convert hearts. 


Your conversion and salvation are in my prayers (daily mass, daily rosary). Because you seriously seek the truth, I’m confident like many other protestants… your hearts will be stirred by Mother Mary, Jesus and Joseph to go back to the Mother Church and be obedient to Pope Francis and be stirred by the Holy Spirit to cease saying the words “non servium”. [sic] We’ll pray for you and our brothers and sisters baptized in the One True Church and for the likes of the SSPX. Keep me also in your prayers…




MHFM: Since Alvin (in his blindness) considers the true Catholic position to be that of ‘Protestants,’ we posed the following question in response.  It concerned his view of Protestants.


Do you accept the teaching of Vatican II and Francis that Protestants are in the Church of Christ, or do you accept the teaching of the Catholic Church that they are outside the Church of Christ?


The question was specific.  It dealt with the teaching of Vatican II on Protestants.  Having Alvin answer the question would force him to confront the truth to which he is blind: i.e., that the Vatican II sect and Francis reject Catholic teaching on Protestants and others who dissent from Catholic teaching.  Not surprisingly, Alvin did not answer the question.  His failure to answer the question is another example of how heretics, being under the control of the Devil, struggle to answer questions directly.


Although Alvin did not answer the question directly, he did respond by diverting into a separate but related matter: the Church’s teaching on the necessity of the Catholic faith for salvation.  Alvin’s response made it clear that he rejects the Church’s defined dogma Outside the Church There is No Salvation.  Alvin’s rejection of that dogma is one of the main reasons he’s an apostate who cannot see the truth.  He writes:


Those not in communion with Mother Church is [sic] outside the Church or are non-catholics I believe that teaching of the Church fully but with regards to salvation of those not in communion with The Church, those outside the church including atheists, protestants and pagans (which atheists really are for they have a false god- themselves and science) with regards to that there are different interpretation of that from different priests. I’ve heard three interpretations from priests so far: 


1) the popular one- strictly those who are not catholics will not be saved which means that around 75% of the world should the world ends and Jesus comes goes to hell 


2) outside the Church actually means those catholics who are lukewarm, those catholics (which are most) who only hear the Teachings yet do not follow, those catholics who are not the “good soil”


3) non-catholics like pagans (again must include atheists) and protestants can be saved but it’ll be very difficult for them, almost impossible


Of the three interpretations by catholic priests in the context of unfathomable mercy and in the context of, God will judge use by how we did things with great charity/love (Cor. Ch. 13), the interpretation I go for is no. 3. It’s the interpretation given to be by a priest I confessed every week during college (every two weeks now). I go for no. 3


God bless,



MHFM: Alvin thus makes it clear that he believes souls can be saved without the Catholic faith and in false religions.  That of course is heresy.  Alvin denies the Church’s dogma as it has been defined and declared.  He’s a heretic.  He’s not a Catholic.  Yet, in his tremendous blindness he thinks true Catholics are outside the Church; and he writes to them with arrogance as if they need conversion to his sect.   What an abomination.


Pope Innocent III, Fourth Lateran Council, Constitution 1, 1215, ex cathedra“There is indeed one universal Church of the faithful, outside of which nobody at all is saved, in which Jesus Christ is both priest and sacrifice.”


Pope Boniface VIII, Unam Sanctam, Nov. 18, 1302, ex cathedra:

“With Faith urging us we are forced to believe and to hold the one, holy, Catholic Church and that, apostolic, and we firmly believe and simply confess this Church outside of which there is no salvation nor remission of sin… Furthermore, we declare, state, define, and pronounce to every human creature that to be subject to the Roman Pontiff is absolutely necessary for salvation.


Pope Clement V, Council of Vienne, Decree # 30, 1311-1312, ex cathedra:

“Since however there is for both regulars and seculars, for superiors and subjects, for exempt and non-exempt, one universal Church, outside of which there is no salvation, for all of whom there is one Lord, one faith, and one baptism…”


Pope Eugene IV, Council of Florence, Sess. 8, Nov. 22, 1439, ex cathedra:

Whoever wishes to be saved, needs above all to hold the Catholic faith; unless each one preserves this whole and inviolate, he will without a doubt perish in eternity.”


Pope Eugene IV, Council of Florence, “Cantate Domino,” 1441, ex cathedra:

“The Holy Roman Church firmly believes, professes and preaches that all those who are outside the Catholic Church, not only pagans but also Jews or heretics and schismatics, cannot share in eternal life and will go into the everlasting fire which was prepared for the devil and his angels, unless they are joined to the Church before the end of their lives; that the unity of the ecclesiastical body is of such importance that only for those who abide in it do the Church’s sacraments contribute to salvation and do fasts, almsgiving and other works of piety and practices of the Christian militia produce eternal rewards; and that nobody can be saved, no matter how much he has given away in alms and even if he has shed blood in the name of Christ, unless he has persevered in the bosom and unity of the Catholic Church."






... I have been listening to you many videos and find the truths within them fascinating.





Next Archive for the E-Exchanges is Here (First 2014 Archive –beginning around January)


Next Archive for the E-Exchanges is Here (Third 2013 Archive –beginning around September)

Next Archive for the E-Exchanges is Here (Second 2013 Archive –beginning around May)

Next Archive for the E-Exchanges is Here (First 2013 Archive –beginning around Jan.)

Next Archive for the E-Exchanges is Here (Fall 2012 Archive)

Next Archive for the E-Exchanges is Here (Summer 2012 Archive)

Next Archive for the E-Exchanges is Here (Spring 2012 Archive)

Next Archive for the E-Exchanges is Here (Fall 2011 Archive)

Next Archive for the E-Exchanges is Here (Summer 2011 Archive)

Next Archive for the E-Exchanges is Here (Spring 2011 Archive)

Next Archive for the E-Exchanges is Here (Winter 2010-2011 Archive)

Next Archive for the E-Exchanges is Here (Summer-Fall 2010 Archive)

Next Archive for the E-Exchanges is Here (Winter 2010 Archive)

Next Archive for the E-Exchanges is Here (A)

Next Archive for E-Exchanges is Here (B)