Oct. 24, 2006 Debate on Sedevacantism: Are the Post-Vatican II claimants to the Papacy true Popes? William Golle (Yes) vs. Bro. Michael Dimond and Bro. Peter Dimond (No)

*The program might take a minute or so to start playing. To play simply click; to download right click and “save target as.”

Click here to listen to the debate (about 3 hrs.)

Mr. Golle is a writer for the Catholic Star Herald (Camden diocesan newspaper) who studies the issue of sedevacantism. Mr. Golle has a degree in Systematic Theology from Seton Hall University and he is working toward his Masters Degree. Listen to this very interesting 3-hour debate. There are sessions of opening statements, rebuttals, detailed questions and answers. See whose position stands the test of truth when the issues are dealt with in a format where they cannot be evaded or ignored. The true position will be obvious to those who sincerely listen to this debate.

We also added this debate Youtube. You can watch all 19 parts online.

The breakdown is, roughly:

Parts 1-2: Golle’s opening statement

Part 1

Part 2

Parts 3-4: Our opening statement

Part 3

Part 4

Parts 5-6: Golle’s next rebuttal

Part 5

Part 6

Parts 6-7: Our next rebuttal

Part 6

Part 7

Parts 8-14: Questions and Answers Cross Examination

Part 8

Part 9

Part 10

Part 11

Part 12

Part 13

Part 14

Part 15: Golle’s next rebuttal

Part 15

Part 16: Our next rebuttal

Part 16

Part 17: Golle’s closing statement

Part 17

Part 18-19: Our closing statement

Part 18

Part 19

Notice how, for example, there is no answer whatsoever to (among other things) Vatican II’s heretical teaching on religious liberty. From Part 10:

Part 10